Example report

An evaluator used the Rubicon plugin for Claude to answer one evaluation question from a set of interviews.

The question
People were trained to pass on Making Every Contact Count (MECC) health training in their own organisations. What stopped some of them, and what helped the rest?
The interviews
13 people who attended the training in the North East of England, from a published study by Northumbria University and colleagues (Nichol et al. 2026, CC BY). The transcripts come from a study by Beth Nichol and colleagues at Northumbria University, who deposited them openly alongside their published paper. Few studies do this. It is excellent practice, and it is what makes an example like this possible.
Against the published study
Checking an AI answer against a published study sets this answer against the researchers' own findings, and checks it sentence by sentence against the transcripts.
Other analyses
What Claude wrote without the plugin, given a shorter version of the question and the same interviews, with a blind check of its answer and of the published paper's results against the transcripts. An evaluator also used the plugin on the same transcripts to judge, against a rubric, how likely MECC delivery is to continue.

Rubicon report

What stopped and what helped MECC cascade

Click any underlined number, or “sources”, to read the passages behind it.

Question What stopped attenders of the MECC Train the Trainer session from going on to deliver (cascade) the training in their own organisations, and what helped the ones who did, comparing the attenders the document list records as having cascaded with those it records as not having cascaded, and including what interviewees report about other attenders they trained, managed or met?

Every attender the document list records as having cascaded had an organisation that wanted MECC delivered, against of those recorded as not (). Most of those who cascaded also had delivery in their job (), but so did of those who did not. What stopped the others was mainly other work with no protected time ( who did not cascade, against who did), and for some a line manager who set no expectation, gave no time or did not sign off (, against ; ). Confidence did not separate the two groups: most of those who did not cascade felt able to deliver, and several who did cascade were nervous (). When interviewees describe other attenders, the commonest accounts are these ():

15 interviews in 3 groups · 822 passages coded · 10 November 2026 · Run 2026-10-22-sb4m

  • What was automatically checked in this reportChecked when this report was created
  • 58 numbers, every one computed by fixed rules from the coded passages or the documents' own facts, rather than written by the AI.
  • 822 quotations, every one found word for word in its interview. Click an interview's ID beside a quotation to read it in place.
  • 9 key claims tagged as numbers are, each with the passages for it and against it and why they bear it out. Click a claim's tag to see them.
  • 167 sentences of the answer were read against the interviews by a second AI reader, separate from the one that wrote them.
  • Not checked: whether the passages cited are all the documents hold on each point, or whether each is labelled correctly.
  • lack of confidence;
  • not realising the session committed them to deliver;
  • not being trainers in their own jobs;
  • no time or management support back at work;
  • a cascade halted by COVID while the training faded.

I am fairly sure that organisational backing and time separate those who cascaded from those who did not, because interviewees on both sides draw the link themselves; I am not sure about job role or line managers. These findings rest on and attenders.

YesNo
Support networks
Organisational priority
Getting an audience
Co-delivery and buddying
Ready-made resources
Trainer confidence
Fit of the core training
Job role
Personal motivation
The TtT session
Line manager
Trainee receptiveness
Platforms and admin
Understanding the content
Time and workload0
Pay and incentives0
Time lapse and refreshers0
Follow-up and structure0
Disruption00
Knowing delivery was expected00
OTHER00
Attenders describing each kind of facilitator that was actually present for their own delivery of MECC training, by whether the document list records them as having cascaded, out of the 7 recorded as cascaded and the 6 recorded as not. Attenders in each group. Click a count for its passages.

The chart above shows, for each kind of help that was actually in place, how many attenders in each group described it.

What helped: the organisation wanted it, and often the job included it

Every attender recorded as cascading described an organisation that wanted MECC delivered (), against of those recorded as not; this difference is clear, since it would survive one document being read the other way. Most who cascaded also said delivering training was part of their job (), but of those who did not cascade also described a role that included or allowed delivery, so the difference on job role is unclear with this few documents ().

  • (NHS): "because working public health it’s my job to deliver that training, so I have time set aside to do that" (). 's line manager set the pace: "my line manager said we need to set up some sessions, we need to get them rolling" ().
  • (local authority): "It was part of my job description as well, so I knew that that was this deliverable that had to kind of be delivered on" ().
  • (local authority): "So, I’ve done a couple of sessions already, so it is in my job role" ().
  • (NHS): "the other part of my role was to develop or deliver the MECC program of work across the organization" (). had been delivering MECC for about a year before attending the TtT session, so for the session followed delivery rather than leading to it.
  • (local authority) pointed to a director of public health "really keen to embed MECC" () and to MECC training in "our public health plan" (). has delivered one co-delivered session and otherwise meets the council's demand by commissioning a charity ().
  • (voluntary sector) delivers under a council contract: "we applied for the bid ... and we won the bid so we’re delivering it" (). The contract brings "a little income for our company" (). Funding of this kind appears only on the cascading side ( who cascaded, against who did not), a difference that is unclear with this few documents. On the other side says of delivering, "I get nothing for it" (), though puts 's own delivery down to "my own passion" ().

and are the exceptions on job role. (NHS) did not describe delivery as part of the job: described a trust push on physical health ("as long as you’re going to use it kind of thing, and obviously I have done"; ), and then took over a session the trust's MECC lead had already planned (). So delivered through a slot someone else had arranged, while in an induction period that, says, leaves "a little bit more time at the moment" (). , who coordinates MECC for the council, is "more after looking after the trainers that we’ve got" () and is "not from a training background" (). 's backing was also qualified: thinks the managers are "worried about the amount of time it will take" ().

Those who cascaded also had more ready routes to an audience ( who cascaded, against who did not), though this difference too is unclear with this few documents. They slotted MECC into time that already existed, such as 's "weekly CPD hour" (), 's induction and preceptorship programmes (), or 's induction and preceptee days (). Or someone else did the recruiting: in 's organisation, "she does the recruitment so she makes sure we’ve got people on the courses" (). says what the ready-made slot was worth: "if we hadn’t already got the system up for CPD it would be like trying to find a time, trying to find a place, trying to find a spot and trying to put it in the diaries" ().

Co-delivery and backing from a local MECC lead or the regional team were common among those who cascaded:

  • co-delivery, buddying or observing: ();
  • support from a local MECC lead or the regional team: ().

Those who did not cascade mention both nearly as often: and . 's co-delivery was arranged but not yet carried out (), and had only an offer from a fellow attender to deliver together (). So neither kind of help on its own explains who delivered. 's experience as a trust lead points the same way. set up sessions for newly trained staff so that "everything else is taken care of" (), yet of "34 staff since September last year" does not think any, "other than these three, have delivered one session" ().

The accounts against this finding are those where backing was present and delivery still had not happened:

  • 's organisation planned "to roll it out and train other members of staff" (), and management agreed to the changes asked for (), but 's sessions were still to come when interviewed.
  • 's management was "Totally supportive of me delivering it" (), but had still not delivered when interviewed. Asked whether having delivery in the job would help, answered "Not for me, because my own work’s fairly well self-directed" ().
  • 's boss backed health and wellbeing training (), but was the same line manager whose sign-off stalled the training § What stopped them: no time, and for some no manager pushing or signing off.
  • described public health backing as "massively supported" (), but only after moving to a new role § Who counts as having cascaded.

What stopped them: no time, and for some no manager pushing or signing off

Every attender recorded as not cascading described work getting in the way (), against who cascaded; this difference is clear ():

  • : "time has been a huge factor because we’ve had loads of sickness in our team so we’ve been really short staffed" (). The task "just kept getting pushed because I had also just completed and audit" ().
  • came back from sick leave to "a backlog of probably more pressing things" (). links this to the job: "this isn’t a core part of my job, it’s something that I’ve chosen to do" ().
  • , a volunteer and trustee, named an election-agent role () and trustee duties, though would not call the trustee role "hugely time consuming" ().
  • named the time needed to go out to teams, and a staff shortage that 's leaving made worse ().
  • For , the difficulty was the work of organising the cascade itself, which "has added a massive amount to workload" ().

's account partly goes against this finding: called the sign-off "the only issue" (), and raised time only when asked about other barriers, as something that would slow delivery after left. The two who cascaded and described time as a barrier that had actually got in their way spoke mostly of capacity to deliver at scale (). expects that a full caseload would make it "really, really difficult" ().

A line manager held delivery back for who did not cascade and who did, a difference that is unclear with this few documents:

  • (public sector) was confident and had arranged how to book sessions, but "needed signoff before I could send the email" (). "Getting signed off from the line management was the main issue" (). The line manager "had a massive workload, she’s just been promoted so she was doing like two job roles at the same time" (). left the job without delivering.
  • 's manager "forgot about it and there was kind of no expectation, you have to then present it within three months, six months or whatever" (). At appraisal the manager "just kind of agreed and said yeah, that’s fine" when suggested not delivering ().
  • In 's former clinical role the manager refused time with the team: "I don’t have time to give you" ().

's case also involved an organisational process. The training was held up waiting for bespoke slides from a partner organisation that were still not ready when left ().

Two further barriers were reported on both sides, so neither separates the groups:

  • No structure or follow-up after the session. described "this gap. There was a void where I would say right, I’m ready to do what" () and "the course is finished, goodbye" (). had one follow-up call from the trust, which the caller dropped on hearing of 's circumstances (). Own accounts of missing follow-up: who did not cascade, against who did ().
  • Support and platforms that were hard to reach or use. Support was unreachable or unused for who did not cascade, against who did. "didn’t know who to ask" (), and found the trainers' forum uncomfortable: "It was just a bit embarrassing for me being in these meetings" (). The online platforms were a barrier for who did not cascade, against who did: "I do find the Futures platform really clunky" (); "I got lost in it" (). , by contrast, knew support was there if needed ().

Not knowing what the session committed them to was described by who did not cascade and who did:

  • heard "now you have to deliver four sessions" and thought "how" ();
  • , who had agreed when a manager asked to train the team, took in what that meant only in the room: "oh wowser, this is what I’ve signed up for" ();
  • knew from the title that delivery was expected but "wasn’t quite sure what was going to be expected from me as a trainer" ().

Illness or a personal crisis right after the session delayed and made "just shelve that" (). For , confidence then faded with time: "it wanes away the less you have to do with it" ().

YesNo
Getting an audience
Support networks
Fit of the core training
Time and workload
Platforms and admin
Trainee receptiveness
Ready-made resources
Trainer confidence
Understanding the content
Disruption
Organisational priority
Line manager
Follow-up and structure
Time lapse and refreshers
Knowing delivery was expected0
Job role
Personal motivation0
The TtT session
Co-delivery and buddying0
Pay and incentives0
OTHER00
Attenders describing each kind of barrier that actually stood in the way of their own delivery of MECC training, by whether the document list records them as having cascaded, out of the 7 recorded as cascaded and the 6 recorded as not. Attenders in each group. Click a count for its passages.

The chart above shows, for each kind of barrier that actually got in the way, how many attenders in each group described it.

Confidence was not what separated them

Most attenders who did not cascade felt able to deliver (), as did of those who did ():

  • : "Oh, I was really confident. I would have done it the next week." ()
  • has "a post graduate certificate in adult education" ().
  • is used to "standing up delivering health lifestyle sessions" every week ().

Several who did cascade described nerves:

  • : "it was a bit nerve wracking because as I say, I’ve never done it before" ();
  • : "I’m quite introverted" ();
  • : "still do feel a little nervous beforehand" ().

Own confidence barriers: who cascaded and who did not. Those who cascaded delivered despite nerves, often with a co-trainer or a slot already arranged.

Confidence did hold back two attenders who did not cascade, which is the account against this finding:

  • does not think of themself as "a natural presenter and teacher" (), and felt uneasy teaching experienced colleagues what "they’re doing day in and day out" ().
  • , asked by a manager in the public health role to deliver the core course, avoided it because "it was causing me stress" (). ties this to not understanding the slides, not to delivering as such ().

What those who cascaded still had to overcome

Those who cascaded met the core training's length and weight once they delivered it, and they adapted, cut or rebuilt it to fit (). The fit of the core training was a barrier for who cascaded, against who did not. Adapting it was a help for who cascaded.

  • found it "Really long. The first time I did it I was like, my God, I’m doing the training and even I’m a bit like bored" (), and added a group activity ().
  • "took two of them out and just kept the stages of change" ().
  • "did have to do a lot of work adapting it and making it comfortable for me to deliver" ().
  • cut it because people were saying "there’s no way we can release staff for three hours" ().

Getting trainees into the room was hard on both sides ( who cascaded and who did not). Those who cascaded describe low turnout () and silent online audiences (). For the main difficulty is reaching shift, part-time and casual staff across "five different centres" (), and selling the training to the team leads who must release them ().

What interviewees report about other attenders

Accounts of other attenders come mostly from those who now lead or coordinate MECC (, , , , ), and also from , , , , , and about colleagues or people they met on the session. Lack of confidence is the commonest, reported by interviewees, and only as a guess ():

  • : "it’s not about having all those answers, but I think it's the confidence to do that training" ();
  • 's trained staff say "I don't feel confident or comfortable delivering the MECC training" ();
  • recalls attenders from other organisations who "weren’t trainers" and "were really a bit nervous on the course", and thinks their roll-out "probably hasn’t happened" ().

Not knowing they had signed up to deliver was reported by interviewees ():

  • : colleagues "didn’t understand they had to deliver training" (), and managers "were putting people forward just because they thought they were going to become aware of MECC" ();
  • : on hearing the expectation, "everybody was like side eyes looking at each other like oh my God, what have we done" ();
  • : "some people will do it and maybe not realise that they have to deliver training" ();
  • thinks there were "potentially people on the course" who "maybe didn’t necessarily want to go and cascade it to others" ().

Against this, 's council has "always kind of made it explicit that you’re expected to if you do it" (). A formal commitment did not settle this on its own either. 's trust asks trainees to "deliver four core MECC sessions within a year" (), yet estimates that "maybe 10% of those staff" deliver routinely ().

Interviewees also describe the same divide by job role among others ():

  • says the trainees who do deliver are "probably the ones where there's opportunities within their job already to deliver education" ().
  • adds that trainees "go away, back to their workplaces, and they aren't supported to deliver their training when they get there" ().
  • 's trainees "weren’t necessarily in that kind of role" ().
  • says attenders from other organisations are "not necessarily trainers in their roles" ().
  • 's trained colleagues hand requests back to the colleague whose job it is: "Oh well, that’s ()’s pot" ().

Time back at work was reported for others by interviewees. 's trainees "have a day job and so I think they found it very difficult to prioritise MECC" ().

Whole cascades stalled when COVID struck ():

  • 's trust trained "about 70 or 80 staff in MECC Train the Trainer, and then it was COVID that stopped that" (). "It just went out of their minds" (). Since then "a lot of them have either moved jobs or they haven’t got the capacity to do it anymore, or they don’t feel comfortable" ().
  • reports the same for an earlier group, of whom "most people disengaged" (): "with COVID everything just stopped" ().
  • 's own first attendance stalled in the same way and turned into delivery only after a refresher session and the council contract ().

The help interviewees gave or offered others was mainly co-delivery and shadowing ( interviewees): offered "the kind of shadowing, the cofacilitating" (), and 's colleague comes along before delivering (). When the interviewer put two strategies to them, interviewees gave them as what would help attenders in general:

  • peer support networks: ;
  • refresher training: .

doubted a refresher: "I don’t know if refresher Train the Trainer would really work" (). Where the leads already run such support, few come: 's trainers' group has a low turnout (), and of 's "80 odd staff I think I only got about 10 that came along" (). calls peer support "A lovely idea, but practically it’s time" ().

Who counts as having cascaded

The document list records attenders as having cascaded and as not. The interviews mostly agree:

  • all those recorded as cascading describe delivering ();
  • of those recorded as not cascading say they had not delivered.

and had sessions booked or in preparation at the time of the interview: has "two courses booked but they haven’t been delivered yet" (), and is preparing sessions with colleagues (). So for them, not having cascaded means not yet.

The exception is , recorded as not cascading ():

  • After moving into a public health role, describes delivering MECC within care certificate training ().
  • In the same role, avoided delivering the core course when asked ().
  • In the former clinical role, had no time to deliver at all ().

This answer keeps among those who did not cascade, as the document list has it. 's account fits the main finding: what delivery there was followed the move into a role where "it’s part of my role" ().

Limitations

  • The groups are small, and they differ in other ways: women make up of those recorded as cascading and of those recorded as not. So the contrast shows what these attenders describe, not a measured effect. Whether delivery was part of the job cannot be told apart from other differences between the people who held such jobs.
  • Each count records whether an interviewee raised a factor, not how much it weighed. The interviews followed a common guide but went into different detail, so a factor someone did not mention may still have mattered to them.
  • Barriers and helps were sorted by whether they had actually happened or were only what would help. Some passages were close calls, especially general remarks grounded in the speaker's experience, and the counts of help in place rest on that sorting.
  • The accounts of other attenders are second-hand. Most come from interviewees who coordinate MECC and describe their own colleagues and trainees, not a sample of attenders.
  • The clear difference in organisational backing ( of those who did not cascade) rests on not reading as backing for delivery either 's organisation's stalled work on bespoke slides () or 's account of an expectation from the trust, told to attenders at the session, that they would deliver; read both as backing, the difference would be unclear.
  • The difference on job role is unclear because 's self-directed role () and 's usual training roll-outs () are read as roles that included or allowed delivery (); also says delivery is not in 's job plan, and read the other way for both, the difference would be clear.
  • Lack of confidence leads the accounts of other attenders by one interviewee ( against ); if 's guess about people on 's course () were read as a general view, not one about specific attenders, the two would be level as the commonest account.

Annexes

How this report was written

What was read. Rubicon read 13 of the 15 documents in full, chosen among those with “role” attender. The counts below are of attenders, one document each.

Coding. It then read each document as a whole and recorded whether the interviewee says, in the interview, that they have themselves delivered MECC training to others since attending the TtT session. It also marked every passage that bears on the question and recorded whether the passage describes something that hindered or something that helped delivering MECC training to others, whose cascading the passage is about, whether the passage describes the factor as actually present or having happened, or only as what would help or hinder and one specific barrier or facilitator to delivering MECC training after the TtT session, with its direction, in the speaker's words where possible, such as 'no protected time to deliver training' or 'manager released staff to attend sessions'. It grouped the labels of label into themes, which became a codebook, and placed each passage under one of them.

Checking. A separate reader then read the answer against the passages it cites and the documents, and checked every sentence and quotation, so the coding and the answer in this report are the corrected ones, counted again after the check.

Counting. Attenders were then counted in 8 tables, compared by these codings. The annex below gives each.

Claims. The writer tagged 9 key claims that rest on no count, as each number is tagged: each names the passages for it and against it, how they would be found again and why they bear it out, and fixed rules checked that every passage named is one the coding holds.

Writing and checks. Rubicon wrote the answer from these counts, citing for each finding the passages it rests on. Every number in the answer, 58 in all, was computed by fixed rules from the coded passages or the documents' own facts, rather than written by the AI, and all 822 coded passages were found word for word in their documents; every quotation in the answer, 96 in all, was found in the documents.

The workflow x-ray beside Step by step, below, draws the same procedure, a box for each stage and what it made.

Step by step

The analysis was written down as a workflow before it was counted: what to look for, how to code it, what to count. It was then counted directly from the coded passages or the documents' own facts rather than by the AI, so anyone can check a number, and another coder can follow the same definitions and code the interviews afresh.

What was read

All 15 documents, read in full: 6 no, 7 yes, 2 .

Sampling: Attenders

Coding: Status

one row for each document, read whole; 13 rows.

The instruction a second coder would follow
Read the whole interview with a person who attended the MECC Train the Trainer (TtT) session. Say whether, by the time of the interview, this person says they have themselves delivered MECC training (the core MECC training or an adapted version of it, as a trainer, to colleagues, staff, volunteers or other professionals) since attending the TtT session. Quote the passage that shows it.
Delivered in transcript

Whether the interviewee says, in the interview, that they have themselves delivered MECC training to others since attending the TtT session.

CodeMeansCountsDoes not count
The interviewee says they have delivered MECC training to others, in full or adapted, since the TtT session.Running sessions of the core MECC training or an adapted or shortened version for staff, volunteers or partner professionals; co-delivering it with a colleague.Having MECC conversations with service users (that is practising MECC, not training others): goes to not_delivered unless training is also described. Training delivered only before the TtT session: goes to not_delivered.
The interviewee says they have not delivered MECC training to others since the TtT session.Saying they have not delivered it, have only planned to, or have only had MECC conversations or promoted MECC without training anyone.Delivering a session that included MECC content as a trainer: goes to delivered.
UnclearThe interview does not make clear whether the interviewee has delivered MECC training since the TtT session.Accounts that leave it open, such as mentioning MECC content in other teaching without saying whether it was MECC training.A clear statement either way.
The coded passages 13 rows
Delivered 8 passages
  • So, I’ve done a couple of sessions already, so it is in my job role.
  • We have a link worker, and I delivered my first training the other day.
  • but we delivered MECC training to their team a couple weeks ago
  • Yes. So, I did the finance module, so we had 17 people on that one.
  • So, and then obviously I delivered, I’ve delivered that training now for well I’m going to say somewhere between 22 and 26 times. Exact numbers I’m not sure. I’ve done about 20 something sessions.
  • Then coming into public health, there was an expectation that you delivered some type, so once I saw it delivered at care certificate level and what we’re delivering, I embraced that. I’ve offered to be the main care certificate deliverer because there’s a lot of people that don’t like to have that conversation with people.
  • I mean I have delivered kind of face to face MECC. I delivered a face-to-face MECC session with a community organisation that worked really well just because the participants knew each other, they had a kind of a regular meeting place.
  • So, me and a colleague went to do the train the trainer session and then we applied for the bid from (name of location) Council to actually go and deliver the training and we won the bid so we’re delivering it. We seem to be doing one or two a month, so it’s going quite well.
Not delivered 5 passages
  • We haven’t. The problem we’ve got is we’ve got such a wide net to cast over our sites and also, it’s getting the people at the same time.
  • It was just a bit embarrassing for me being in these meetings and everyone else is talking about what they’re doing and I’m like yeah, I’ve not done anything yet, I’ve got a big project to do.
  • or you’ve got me saying well I’m sorry but I haven’t really done anything in that respect.
  • My personal circumstances meant that I had an illness not long after I went on it and was off sick for a period of time, hence I have got two courses booked but they haven’t been delivered yet.
  • I said to my manager I’ve done the train the trainer, the MECC Train the Trainer training, in November and haven’t done anything with that

Coding: Label

one row for each passage that fits; 809 rows.

The instruction a second coder would follow
Read the interview with a person who attended the MECC Train the Trainer (TtT) session, whose aim is that attenders go on to deliver (cascade) core MECC training within their own organisation. Code every passage in which the interviewee says something stopped, delayed, limited or made harder the delivery of MECC training to others after the TtT session (a barrier), or something helped, enabled or made easier that delivery (a facilitator). Include what they say about their own delivery or plans to deliver, about specific other attenders they trained, managed or met, and their general views of what stops or helps attenders cascade. Give each passage a short label naming one specific thing with its direction, in the speaker's words where possible. A passage holding two different factors gives two rows. Say also whether the factor actually happened or was present, or is only what would help or hinder.
Label

One specific barrier or facilitator to delivering MECC training after the TtT session, with its direction, in the speaker's words where possible, such as 'no protected time to deliver training' or 'manager released staff to attend sessions'. One thing per label: a label that lists two things is two rows.

Kind

Whether the passage describes something that hindered or something that helped delivering (cascading) MECC training to others.

CodeMeansCountsDoes not count
Something that stopped, delayed, limited or made harder delivering MECC training to others after the TtT session.Reasons given for not delivering or not yet delivering; difficulties met while arranging or delivering training; things that would stop or are expected to stop delivery; the absence of something needed (no time, no support, no audience).Criticisms of the TtT session that the speaker does not connect to delivering or not delivering training, such as a dislike of an exercise: not coded. Barriers to having MECC conversations with service users, unconnected with training others: not coded.
Something that helped, enabled or made easier delivering MECC training to others after the TtT session.Things the speaker says made delivery possible or easier; what helped others deliver; what the speaker says would help (a suggested improvement) where it is put as what would enable delivery.General praise for MECC or for the TtT session that the speaker does not connect to delivering training: not coded. A missing support described as missing: that is a barrier.
Whose

Whose cascading the passage is about.

CodeMeansCountsDoes not count
The interviewee's own delivery of MECC training, or their own plans or attempts to deliver it.What stopped or helped the interviewee themselves, including what their own organisation or manager did about their delivery.What happened to colleagues who attended: goes to others.
Named or specific other people who attended TtT training, whom the interviewee trained, managed, worked with or met, and their delivery of MECC training.A colleague who attended TtT and did or did not go on to deliver; staff the interviewee manages or trained as trainers; people met on the TtT session or the trainers' forum and what they said about delivering.Statements about attenders in general or about the TtT model as a whole: goes to general.
The interviewee's general view of what stops or helps attenders cascade MECC training, or of the barriers and strengths of the TtT model, not tied to their own or a specific person's experience.Answers to questions about the barriers or strengths of the TtT model; opinions about what attenders in general need.A general remark that the speaker illustrates only with their own experience: goes to own.
Actual

Whether the passage describes the factor as actually present or having happened, or only as what would help or hinder.

CodeMeansCountsDoes not count
The factor is described as actually present or as having actually happened: something that did help or did hinder, or was in place or missing in fact.'My manager gave me time'; 'nobody contacted me afterwards'; 'the slides were all there'; a settled plan or an existing resource; general wording that reports what actually happened to the speaker or people they describe.A suggestion, wish or hypothetical ('a buddy would have helped'): goes to prospective. A guess about others with no instance: goes to prospective.
The factor is described as what would help, would have helped, or would or might hinder: a suggestion, wish, expectation, hypothetical or opinion not tied to something that happened.'A refresher every year would help'; 'I expect resistance from the staff'; 'it would be daunting for people with no training experience'; a benefit only expected.A worry the speaker holds now while delivering, or a fact with a hypothetical clause attached: goes to actual.
The coded passages 809 rows
Barrier 407 passages
  • I just thought I’m being trained to do something so will I get the opportunity to practice doing what I’m being trained to do.
  • I guess that will be really, really daunting for a lot of people if they’ve never experienced MECC before or any kind of training delivery before.
  • trying to combat any resistance that we might have from staff within the centres as in do I really have to do this.
  • The problem we’ve got is we’ve got such a wide net to cast over our sites and also, it’s getting the people at the same time.
  • Because a lot of the staff that we’ll be cascading this out to work shifts, a lot of them are part time or casual staff
  • and that they’re based across like five different centres.
  • So, it’s been a bit of a challenge logistically to try and find the space and the time to get everybody together.
  • We probably are at different stages and different levels in terms of understanding of MECC, experience of MECC and experience of delivery.
  • but as somebody throws you a curve ball question that you should really know about, but you haven’t got an answer you’re going to end up looking really silly
  • It’s quite tough really because if you’re doing it to a small number of people then it’s probably relatively easy to organise and facilitate, but when you’re doing it to potentially a large number of people
  • I kind of had to put a dampener on a little bit because it’s too many. It’s too big a group and you’d lose a lot of the engagement in a group like that
  • but in this sense it has added a massive amount to workload.
  • In terms of sitting down with team leads and trying to sell it to them and sitting down with managers and trying to organise which staff are doing what
  • a lot of the people we’re going to be delivering to don’t have work emails.
  • so there’s been a bit more of a workload involved in that because we’re going to have to manage potentially 200 paper copies on the first day of training.
  • I think there was only four or five of us on that call. I was expecting something a little bit bigger.
  • a lot of the time I don’t have a great deal of time to go through them in any great detail.
  • I think what didn’t work on that day for some of the team was the Train the Trainer directly following, like immediately following the core training.
  • they’ve decided that (name of organisation)’s going to help create bespoke slides, so they were going to adjust the slides that were available on MECC instead of us doing it ourselves, and they were going to make them more focused around what we were concerned about our risk factors, that sort of thing. And it just took forever.
  • So, I did the MECC training about I think it would have been November 2022, and I left the (public sector service) about a month ago and the slides still hadn’t been prepared.
  • I think because it was such a big number they wanted their stamp on it almost but then the process of them wanting their stamp on it meant it never actually got done because there was so much focus on making it perfect rather than just getting out and doing it.
  • Because it was getting handled at the (name of organisation) side it was then wrapped up in all of the red tape and we just couldn’t get out and get it done.
  • And the example that they gave during our training was health and wellbeing and I thought there’s no way that you’re going to get a (name of role) to go out and talk about diet
  • I don’t know whether it was because my line manager didn’t do as much front line delivery, and she was going to have a part on this one whether it was sort of like nerves on her end, because it is quite difficult to deliver to sort of (audience) who all know each other and you’re coming in as an outsider.
  • It wasn’t really shared with me, it was just oh they’ve offered to help out, it’s going to be fantastic, but then it was [14.46 unclear] delayed.
  • Getting signed off from the line management was the main issue
  • my line manager had a massive workload, she’s just been promoted so she was doing like two job roles at the same time
  • and on the MECC side within (name of organisation), I think they were really busy as well, so I think just the marking up took a long while
  • and then it’s sort of took longer and longer until it got to the point where I was sort of feeling like well it’s no longer fresh in my mind.
  • It was just a bit embarrassing for me being in these meetings and everyone else is talking about what they’re doing and I’m like yeah, I’ve not done anything yet, I’ve got a big project to do.
  • I think that’s probably a problem that’s unique to the (public sector service) in that it’s very structured and hierarchical. So, if you’ve got like a blockage above you, you can’t move through
  • We’ve already had that barrier with the (name of role)s that say well actually, in addition to talk about (redacted for confidentiality) you’re now going to go out and talk about dementia and we already have to get over that barrier of a little bit of that’s not really my thing, I’m not medically trained, I’m not sure if I’m confident with that.
  • and it was quite frustrating knowing I was going out and delivering one type of training and there was a potential that a month later I was going to have to be coming back to deliver the MECC training.
  • a lot of our (name of building)s are built in the fifties, they’ve got terrible wi-fi and not very good IT resources so some of them I might have had a barrier with the slides.
  • Nothing was in place at the time when I was leaving
  • and there’s lots going on at the moment with it coming up to (redacted for confidentiality) and they’re very busy at the moment so I don’t think anything will have happened since I left.
  • and then once that’s approved then you’ve got the strategic issue of getting to be able to get in person and see the (number) (name of role) and booking everything in
  • [33.12 unclear] what’s kind of the point in interacting when everyone else was sort of taking the slides and tweaking them for them self and I’m just waiting on someone else to sign off on it.
  • And I was like yeah, it would be, but it was a bit weird that I wasn’t sort of getting to put my personal touch on it and I wasn’t even delivering anything yet.
  • So, I think there probably would have been a barrier there of if I tweaked the slides and then one of my colleagues went and delivered at a different (name of building) and they wanted to tweak the slides, all the (the teams)s are then going to feel like they’ve not had the same quality of training
  • so I had all the infrastructure there on actually booking it and arranging to go out, it was just I needed signoff before I could send the email saying we’ve got this training to deliver to you.
  • You’ve got to get a little bit more creative when you’re delivering to the (the teams)s because if they’ve decided that they’re not interested in the training and you’re going into that setting, you’ve got to really get them on board
  • I mean getting the time to go out and see them is a barrier and because I’ve left there’s now even more of a staff shortage than there was
  • but the team’s training just doesn’t really seem to work for them, that (name of role)s seem to prefer in person and you going to them.
  • and the new process at (name of organisation) is cost saving, every job has to be reapproved before you can hire for it.
  • it was just our problem was it reached sort of a bottle neck in the process, and we just couldn’t get past it.
  • But getting people to sign up to do train the trainer is a nightmare.
  • But I want you to have some people who do train the trainer. Ooh, no. We just want you to come and train us all. So, they’re really reluctant to then disseminate the training
  • Yeah, but the main thing is they either go on the train the trainer and don’t do anything with it, because there’s people in my team who are trained in MECC.
  • Who then come to me and go oh well there’s this MECC needs delivering to this service, and I’m like well you’re trained in it, go on. Go on.
  • Well, when I’ve spoken to people, one girl’s really keen but she’s not delivered training before, so she’s got to come along with the couple that I’m doing, so I think that is an issue.
  • So, they’re not confident to go and discuss.
  • but people aren’t comfortable, and I think they’re worried about what they’re going to be asked in the training sessions.
  • So, it’s not about having all those answers, but I think it's the confidence to do that training.
  • people when they talk about health training, they’re like oh I’m not from a health background. Well, it’s not health, it’s signposting.
  • Because of my health background and my job title lends itself to, you know, leading on training and development. Oh well, that’s (AP11)’s pot.
  • But again, they want us to go in and do the training for them and they’re not keen to sign anyone up from the practice for train the trainer.
  • Because they think they don’t want to take that responsibility
  • I think the idea is just blanket training across the board, I think it’s a ticky box thing.
  • You know, it ticks a box whereas having someone in your service takes like that extra additional time
  • But I wonder if it’s how we’re selling the train the trainer as well. Is it seen as a arduous task that, you know, an additional responsibility that someone’s taken on.
  • I mean the person who did it before me was like it’s a massive amount of work that.
  • Yeah, so you know, it’s a good offer if you sign someone up to do train the trainer, and then I think the way we do the training, to be honest I think the MECC core is really, really wordy.
  • Really long. The first time I did it I was like, my God, I’m doing the training and even I’m a bit like bored.
  • Yeah, so I’ve got the video in and then I’ve added in like a group activity, there’s no group activities or anything in the core MECC so I do worry that people are just like whoa, you know. It’s a long time.
  • Because I think if you’re going to ask someone to then train that and they don’t have that background, if you make it too overly complicated, they’re going to go all right, yeah I’ll do the train the trainer and then they go nah, you know, I don’t feel confident because I don’t actually understand that part myself.
  • It’s very ‘we already do that’.
  • But as I say, I don’t think that’s as easy for other people if they hadn’t done training before and they haven’t come from a health background or a public health background, I think that could be a bit daunting.
  • But as I say, I don’t think that’s as easy for other people if they hadn’t done training before and they haven’t come from a health background or a public health background, I think that could be a bit daunting.
  • Well, it is because NHS background’s usually we’ll train you, see one, do one, off you go kind of background.
  • whereas my colleague who did the training with me is then coming with me to do further, you know, to observe the training that I do, and I wonder if that’s because she’s not that kind of see one, do on, off you go kind of learner.
  • No. Probably not. There wasn’t. So, it was basically me having an [35.33 unclear] round Future NHS because some of the emails you get are really, really long.
  • Those emails that from MECC. And I attended the MECC regional conference thing and that’s really long and quite often there’s people talking about things that probably it’s very NHS sort of led and clinical and that’s not where I sit now.
  • I think they are worried about the amount of time it will take
  • And I’m like I can really push train the trainer, but people are loath to sign up to it.
  • until people see the value of MECC they’re not going to get on board.
  • I would love to make it mandatory but that’s like not happening.
  • Very long. Very, very long. I mean, you’re talking like two and a half hours.
  • I mean they’re not very often, but it is really long and it’s a bit of a showcasey this is what I’ve done, this is how I’ve done it.
  • So, I think that peer support is fantastic. However, I think people are afraid to ask.
  • Well yeah, until I did it the other day and then I was like ooh.
  • I mean like your brief interventions around mental health, when you’re training the mental health nurses it’s a bit like suck eggs grandma, you know
  • it was a bit daunting at first because I’ve never done it before
  • No. No. Just timing, you know. It’s just crazy.
  • So, obviously if I’d got a full caseload then trying to fit anything in would be really, really difficult.
  • and sometimes it’s like I obviously don’t know enough sort of thing, you know, it can sort of be a bit like that but then you have to think well this is their job.
  • so you can only do so much but it does make you think am I good enough to do this, can I do…do I know enough, not that I’m not good enough, do I know enough to do this, etc.
  • Because actually because it was delivered online you don’t get the feedback do you.
  • You know, it’s like the visual feedback and I mean a few times when I asked people, you know, has anybody got an idea about this, it was like stony silence.
  • and obviously we don’t always have as much time so some of the bits that were slightly less relevant, you know, we hid the slides and stuff like that
  • I mean, it was a bit nerve wracking because as I say, I’ve never done it before.
  • I prefer face to face but obviously that’s a lot more time consuming for people
  • So, if she ever needs any help then I would quite happily stack up if I can job wise, job role wise, you know.
  • So, I’ve told her I’ll be wiling to do it so it’s kind of if she needs me.
  • So, that’s because everybody’s so crazy busy. If you’ve got a case load of thirty, obviously an hour’s CPD is, or two hours whatever it is, is massive.
  • A lovely idea, but practically it’s time.
  • you’re going to take the patient every time and we’re just so, I mean you know, it’s like everywhere, we’ve got staff sickness, staff illness etc. etc. etc. We’re just too busy really.
  • hope that staff would drop into that because its not mandatory training
  • but ultimately, coming off the back of COVID, we’re a really time pressured organization, obviously you’ve got staff working in wards etc
  • MECC I think, it's still an issue now, but MECC is hard to get up people's agenda in terms of a priority
  • it was very labor intensive doing the core MECC, as its called now the core MECC, 1 1/2 hour sessions online, hoping that people would join, but actually, really, the numbers through that program were very very low.
  • because from a sustainability point of view, really, really challenging with one or two people delivering an hours training every week forevermore.
  • But core MECC has always been an issue, and I think that's standard across the different organizations in the region because you put on a lot of training, but your numbers are very, or relatively low, should I say.
  • So we, we’ve probably built in too much content to our train the trainer model and our core MECC model
  • So having two or three behavior change models in an hours worth of training just felt a bit heavy for us.
  • so you do feel like you're trying to cram a lot in
  • people go away, back to their workplaces, and they aren't supported to deliver their training when they get there.
  • but I don't have the capacity when I get back into my team
  • either the managers not supportive of the extra time it's going to take
  • or we didn't actually realize what we were signing up to when we came on your programme, even though the clue is kind of in the title a bit
  • or actually, I've really enjoyed it, but I don't feel confident or comfortable delivering the MECC training.
  • That's not, that's not me, and that's not what I want to do.
  • Of those (number), I would say we're lucky to have maybe 10% of those staff delivering core MECC routinely.
  • that's far more MECC sessions than what we as a public health team can deliver. So yeah, we just haven't got that level of capacity in the system.
  • It probably sounds a lot more fancy than what it really is because again, the turn, like the turn out for the group is low
  • ..but you kind of go on and you’re like oh my god I cant get anything to work, I can't find anything on there
  • So I do think people find it overwhelming
  • But again, the problem we have is people don't attend them. They're not mandatory
  • So we recognize that the content of the train the trainer, there's so much to cram in, but actually you're still only getting a whistle stop tour of each of the topic areas.
  • but there was only three people came and I was really disappointed
  • But again, it's just trying to get the buy-in from the organization about how to, you know, we need to support the staff that have done this training to deliver it and to keep their knowledge and skills up.
  • I know I should have done this by now, it's been over a year since I've had the training, but I need a refresher, would you mind?
  • I know I should be doing this and I do want to do it, but I need some additional support, so we offer that.
  • But actually people aren't doing it on the ground.
  • So we've always got some MECC training going on that people can attend, but it does sometimes feel a bit like you’re banging the drum and hoping people will sit up and take notice.
  • Sometimes I think, what are we doing, like all of this, the emailing, the patrolling, the putting on the sessions, all the admin behind it, all the number crunching
  • but very very quickly realized that we couldn't expect staff to set their own training up on that because it was just, there were, I think there were lots of glitches in the system at the time.
  • but we just felt it was another barrier to our staff to navigate that system and then you know, set up that training and then keep tabs on who was signing up and whatnot
  • because we might get 5 people signed up, but then based on past experience, we know those five people probably won't do anything with it.
  • You know we can send them emails but we've got no sort of authority over them
  • because I think probably what's lacking at the minute is like a, maybe a steering group around MECC, like a specific project plan
  • but ultimately again, how much leverage does that have when they're already very busy?
  • if your managers not going to support that, then you're not going to be able to move that forward.
  • I think the feedback I get from staff around the content is that it can be quite overwhelming
  • Say somebody who hasn't got that insight or foundations in public health or health improvement, I do think it can be hard for them to know how to deliver the information on, say the wider determinants
  • if you're not hugely familiar with the signposting options in the trust, how do you get to a place where you think I can talk through hat service confidently
  • And so again, talking through the behaviour change model I don’t think that's the easiest thing to do if you've never come across that before
  • So sometimes yeah, I think on the face of it, it's not technical training, but I think there's elements to it which can be hard for people to deliver confidently.
  • However, saying that is how do you get around to that, how do you organise that training because obviously you need to be involved with other people.
  • And whereas Train the Trainers what are you going to train in? How, what are you going to actually do as Train the Trainers, you know, in what aspect.
  • But as I say, huge, huge sort of area where you could get into, it’s just where do you start.
  • I was motivated certainly when I done the MECC course in that and I was looking forward to it, but the thing what I found was, was this gap. There was a void where I would say right, I’m ready to do what.
  • You know, this as well, and I said yeah well that’s a good thing, what are we going to do.
  • Your subject is so broad, how do you narrow that down to target in on what you want and what you want to achieve.
  • What structure, you know, can be in place to actually try and achieve your objectives and there didn’t seem to be any support in that respect there.
  • Of course, it’s always time as well, and people’s time, you know. And then you can guarantee if you say well, I’m OK for a certain day something will crop up
  • So, it’s really looking within the organisation of it to say right yeah, you’ve done that, how do you carry on from there.
  • I think I could have on hindsight, I think I could have sort of had more interaction with the people who were on the course.
  • No. So, this is what we’re saying where, you know, we’ve done that part but how do you move and use those sort of skills that you’re developing, you know.
  • Whether I’ve missed something along the way doing the training and then from that there hasn’t been really very much within sort of contacting and saying right (AP2), have you got anything, you know, you want to—
  • I think that might be down to me personally, but again I think there should have been more help there and pushing you and saying yeah, you know, get on the app and—
  • if that could have been followed through more and saying well you’ve done the course, how are you progressing now. Well, the course is finished, goodbye.
  • I couldn’t get online for some reason. It was keep getting blocked and what have you.
  • Again, it’s a very busy environment and it’s liaising with the project manager (name), who’s very busy.
  • And I’m also involved in I’m an election agent.
  • Well, it’s a mixture of both but also then the trustee here is it’s not, I wouldn’t say it’s hugely time consuming, but I do like to be obviously involved in lots of aspects of it.
  • Well, it’s a mixture of both
  • No. I must be honest I haven’t as yet.
  • Well, there hasn’t been any positive communication to go on from, from the end of the course so to speak.
  • I imagine some of them will because as I identified, they knew each other but for me it was a little bit in isolation.
  • Then how do you actually practice what you’ve learnt.
  • But I haven’t been encouraged to use them or there hasn’t been—
  • And I haven’t, maybes that not comfy enough to carry on and say right I’ll go online and I’ll—
  • Obviously, you say well where do we go, how much do we pay for a venue. There’s cost attached.
  • there were other people in (name of location) that had done it. But because of COVID hitting, most people disengaged
  • then I know (name) was the regional lead and she’d left.
  • I’d done an online session and I think it was meant to be Train the Trainer, but it was just like a MECC session, like I didn’t feel equipped for delivering MECC after doing the online session.
  • Like it was online because it was during COVID as well, so you don’t quite get the same interaction then
  • But like I say, I said my manager (name), so we were both on it, he felt the same and I just thought if I had to go and deliver it tomorrow, I just wouldn’t be ready.
  • So, I know a couple of people just went straight to the Train the Trainer so they might have struggled a little bit more with not having that prior knowledge.
  • So, I’d only really seen it being delivered online. I wasn’t at the webinar so I couldn’t even ask questions. I was only watch the recording.
  • And again, I was unsure on the 3A slides because they kind of covered them but in too much detail. And then when I had to deliver it, it was a little bit winging it.
  • Like I said at the beginning, I didn’t have the capacity to do it once a month, so they’ve got a two-year contract.
  • But yeah, if I deliver it myself, I probably have to just read through a couple of times.
  • And it’s like I said, you just kind of get a lot of things thrown at you which might be a bit overwhelming for someone without a health background or any prior knowledge.
  • I think that’s why [14.17 unclear] struggled a little bit, they kind of wanted to know more on the conversation side.
  • but again it’s I’m not from a training background so it might just be my insecurity of being a trainer.
  • I’m more after looking after the trainers that we’ve got
  • But I’m quite introverted and even university presentations were quite overwhelming at first.
  • Well, I hadn’t looked at the slides like in a few months and like the panic that set over us
  • so I just feel if they’re in the group they’re a bit more I know this, like a bit more critical.
  • Apart from a couple of months where (name) she’s had an operation.
  • I mean, I could get into it as a lead trainer but then a few people weren’t able to register and it’s just a bit of a pain in the bum where you’re having to get back to them
  • Because it was just kind of online. We’d have to print them ourselves
  • I know when we first started doing finance the certificate was just the core MECC one, so people had done core MECC, they just had a duplicate certificate.
  • I’ve only been to a few of the trainer ones to be honest, and I think one was talking about behavioural insights and there’s normally a clash with something.
  • because it was just kind of a theory and then with COVID everything just stopped.
  • MECC was completely put on the back burner.
  • I suppose the one thing that’s probably came up is some people will do it and maybe not realise that they have to deliver training.
  • Because they were happy to do it, maybe to get a qualification but not—
  • Like, we’ve got (name of location) Fire and Rescue like maybe trying to persuade them to do it. But it’s probably capacity issues as well.
  • But I think it’s a bit hit-and-miss like from what other people, other local authorities have said about picking up this training and who’s just happy to come.
  • Do you not have a group to teach, like do you not feel confident training? Is it capacity?
  • Do you not have a group to teach, like do you not feel confident training? Is it capacity?
  • Do you not have a group to teach, like do you not feel confident training? Is it capacity?
  • it’s probably been (name)’s fault that I wasn’t invited to the webinar.
  • I have to be clear that my remit is only for people working with cancer patients, so I can’t tackle this as a trust
  • but I wasn’t quite sure what was going to be expected from me as a trainer and if it was there it didn’t stick in my mind.
  • I do think that perhaps some people that have signed up to it have gone to do the MECC training rather than the Train the Trainer training.
  • My personal circumstances meant that I had an illness not long after I went on it and was off sick for a period of time, hence I have got two courses booked but they haven’t been delivered yet.
  • So, I think I would have got to it quicker had it not been for I came back to work and actually had a backlog of probably more pressing things that I have to attend to first.
  • Because this isn’t a core part of my job, it’s something that I’ve chosen to do because it feels like it’s the right thing.
  • Trying to book training venues is very hard because as you can imagine there’s a lot of clinical training and mandatory training that has to take place in a trust.
  • I do find the Futures platform really clunky.
  • You sign up to a Modern Futures platform for a number of different things and you do end up bombarded with emails. So, I end up filtering mine into a different inbox and then generally don’t look at them.
  • It isn’t easy, and I’m not totally hopeless with IT. I’m not the best either. Some of the younger and more switched on might be better, but I’m certainly not bad with it and I was really struggling to find everything that I needed.
  • And I think some of that terminology can be confusing
  • You have to go looking for different bits and pieces, and I have to admit I’ve been scratching my head thinking which bits am I supposed to include, what am I supposed to give them.
  • Maybe for other people that might be a little bit of a barrier, it might feel a bit scary
  • There has been the opportunity to take part in the trainer’s forum. As I’ve mentioned I was unwell for a period of time, so I haven’t been able to join in with that yet.
  • Again, I think a link to it in a step-by-step guide would be good because I had to really dig around to find it again after I came back after being off.
  • And I think because that wasn’t there, there were potentially people on the course who would use it in their own practice but maybe didn’t necessarily want to go and cascade it to others.
  • I know the point is to deliver it at scale. It’s that cascade but I do think not everybody would want or feel confident to do that.
  • so people might not feel confident to maybe email (name of regional MECC at scale coordinator) and say oh I can’t find this or I can’t do that, so they just don’t.
  • I happen to be honest that it’s one of those things if my work load’s really high it’s a thing that I can feel I can pass off.
  • I had done some training back in I think 2020 but then COVID came along so I’d kind of forgotten all about that.
  • I mean I was quite nervous about delivering the MECC training because before I started doing it, it wasn’t something that I’d done for long, like for quite a while.
  • But I don’t do that for MECC. I just deliver MECC by myself.
  • I think about 70 or 80 staff in MECC Train the Trainer, and then it was COVID that stopped that.
  • And it just went out of their minds, they didn’t get chance to practice or deliver any training whatsoever.
  • It was kind of like panic stations in terms of wards and capacity and caseloads and stuff like that, so there was absolutely no activity whatsoever on MECC for a good couple of years really.
  • a lot of them have either moved jobs or they haven’t got the capacity to do it anymore, or they don’t feel comfortable.
  • a lot of them have either moved jobs or they haven’t got the capacity to do it anymore, or they don’t feel comfortable.
  • a lot of them have either moved jobs or they haven’t got the capacity to do it anymore, or they don’t feel comfortable. They’re keeping their heads very, very low.
  • And out of the 80 odd staff I think I only got about 10 that came along to that, and even then, I don’t think many of those are delivering now at all.
  • we kind of said we were all in the same boat really trying to reengage with the trainers that had already been trained and it was becoming really difficult.
  • Some people that are trained haven’t done any training and feel really lacking in confidence or just intimidated at the thought of presenting to a group of people.
  • they don’t put their cameras on, they don’t engage often and yeah, you can barely see them.
  • whereas when I’m doing the MECC training by myself there is a lot of flicking between screens and kind of trying to watch out for questions.
  • We haven’t done a lot of face-to-face sessions. Have done a couple but they just they were terribly attended.
  • But yeah, I think people just really feel a bit aggrieved at having to travel these days.
  • people were saying there’s no way we can release staff for three hours, it needs to be sort of half that
  • So, it doesn’t really feel like there’s a lot of time to do those sort of interactive activities
  • In terms of my delivery, I think I’d probably now feel more secure delivering it online just because I’ve done that more often, the sort of doing a face-to-face session now feels a little bit intimidating.
  • and I suppose I kind of worry about people’s reactions to the content of the training.
  • So, it almost feels like will somebody see this as a real waste of time if I’m telling them to have a conversation with somebody and help them and support them when actually that’s what they do.
  • when I’m delivering training I feel like sometimes it’s good to be delivering a bit more knowledge and a bit more specifics about certain topic areas and MECC seemed to not really have room for the specifics.
  • It’s not to say that it’s not…there’s not some work to do around cascading that message more broadly across senior managers.
  • And then more recently some of the other groups like volunteers have come forward and said we’d like to do some training for these groups, and just some of the contacts I tried to make before and it’s fallen a bit flat, kind of not had a response and things.
  • after the first time I could never remember how (name of principal trainer) had kind of woven that into the training and I just never, I’ve never included it in mine
  • Again, I think if the videos had just been a little bit more specific towards our staff, we might have had…it would have been easier to engage some of them a bit better.
  • whereas people who are doing the core, sorry who are receiving the Train the Trainer training, weren’t necessarily in that kind of role.
  • They were practitioners, or they have a day job and so I think they found it very difficult to prioritise MECC around everything else.
  • got so many emails back from people saying I just haven’t got the capacity to deliver this at the moment
  • but I’m not able to have this in my remit notes, it’s not seen as relevant to my role
  • but just they’re exercise therapists or they’re specialist nurses and they might have done it once or twice
  • and I think that other people who are doing this as a sort of add on to their role just don’t have the time to do that.
  • she kind of I suppose was a bit nervous about setting up her first session
  • he sent me an email, bless him, saying I feel like I’ve done, nobody else is interested now, I’ve saturated this site
  • we can’t ask that he goes travelling off to other sites to deliver it because that’s beyond the call of his kind of role.
  • Easy to forget. It’s easy to forget a training session if you haven’t delivered it for a few weeks, never mind a couple of years.
  • I think possibly having a Train the Trainer course on your CV looks very good.
  • It looks really positive, and nobody is going to really ask you whether you actually delivered any sessions or not.
  • perhaps people do really intend to deliver that training at the time that they’re going on it, and then life just takes over.
  • but I don’t remember all that much content in the Train the Trainer sessions about organising your sessions via the app.
  • because I’m doing sessions and promoting them through the bulletin maybe people see them and think oh well the session’s available I won’t bother doing another one
  • because sometimes people are just it’s the IT skills that people struggle with.
  • So, logging on to things like training apps and the NHS, Future NHS forum, and using the passwords and having to log on, I think, becomes a bit of a barrier.
  • I think it scan be a bit daunting looking in it and there’s lots of things in different places
  • I think this training people don’t get it because they don’t understand what you’re trying to train them in.
  • I think it’s the biggest waste of time I’ve ever been at because I didn’t actually understand what they were trying to deliver.
  • They didn’t have a clue what they were trying to deliver and then they were told the expectation was they needed to deliver that four sessions in a year and nobody had a clue about it.
  • So, that’s in all honestly why you lost or why our trust, lost a whole people because they weren’t prepared to do the training because they didn’t understand they had to deliver training.
  • All they thought they were going to say is I’m at a course to become more aware of MECC so when I’m in my job I can be comfortable having MECC conversations.
  • And I was excited about being there because I was trying to network, but then when it stood and went and now you have to deliver four sessions it was like how.
  • Especially when they’re half a day. How do I deliver that?
  • I think it was to become like an ambassador not to deliver training but to be, have a conversation and you and your team say MECC’s great, making sure that our patients have that conversation.
  • But if it comes back as far as I’m concerned it doesn’t give you an idea of what you’re actually trying to do.
  • It shouldn’t be you’re trying to change a well-run physiotherapy department by going in and saying MECC. They’re going to look at you and go what are you talking about.
  • I think as soon as you put training in they’re expecting more.
  • Roll on MECC training and train the trainer as I didn’t know what I was trying to deliver.
  • to me it gives you too much information about public health and we know it impacts but it goes through figures about death rates, etc. etc. etc. then it goes into what you’re trying to deliver through core MECC and even with core MECC I’m like what are you trying to actually get us to deliver.
  • And the other thing was, it was delivered to any level whereas I think the people who designed it, it should have been delivered at a kind of managerial level.
  • Because the people you were saying trying to train, so a Band 3 was then going back to the thing and going Band 7s down, Band 8s down, I’m going to train you in this.
  • And I’ve been honest with my boss, it’s like one of the reasons I don’t do the new slides is it’s way beyond my pay grade.
  • I work for public health but I’m going that’s out with either two things, my pay grade and my remit because this is proper public health.
  • You’ve got Band 2 porters sitting there going I just came to Train the Trainer, I don’t actually understand it, or I’m not interested.
  • when you come to training and you leave, you should be comfortable about having that conversation, not panicking that you’re going to go and have a conversation with your peers about training them in MECC if you don’t understand what MECC is.
  • I’d like to deliver it, but I don’t know how. Haven’t got a clue how I’m going to do it.
  • But then when I spoke to my peers about it from management down, they didn’t show any kind of interest
  • So, then you lose your motivation and then you get the email through saying can you let us know when you’re planning to do your four delivery sessions.
  • I think the problem is there’s an expectation. I think it was an unrealistic expectation because you looked at the stats and went, we want to train, I think it was they wanted to train fifty per cent of the staff so that fifty per cent of the staff would impact the rest of the staff.
  • That in a year’s time you’ve lost a thousand people. You’ve probably lost half the people in there that you’re training.
  • Management don’t have time, especially in a clinical setting, for you to go and say can I have four hours of your team, or three hours of your team, or even an hour of your team to talk about MECC.
  • Like so my boss was respiratory, and she’s like I don’t have time to give you, who do you want. I was like chance to speak to all your team. No.
  • If you’re in an office job or, you know, luckily with public care if they’ll give that time, but actually if you got ward staff, they don’t even have time to do ESR.
  • Public health, but my old role not a hope, you know.
  • it’s not just going to deliver it, it’s the preparation time sorting out. It’s a big sort of ask for the general person in a working environment.
  • For no extra money, so with all due respect as well, to go and deliver that again, say a Band 2 to go and deliver some sort of training, it’s a higher remit. It’s a higher pay grade.
  • So, I’m teaching people that are higher paid than me, I’m delivering an impacted thing so they can become better so they possibly can climb the ladder more because they’re MECC trained, and they’ve become more aware. So, actually that’s probably quite a big thing in their career pathway, but I get nothing for it.
  • But it’s also people will say well why should I do it.
  • And at the end it was like is everybody happy to deliver that. What are we actually trying to deliver? And he went don’t worry, you’ll get the slides.
  • I walked away and I had honest conversations with people because I knew a few people who were in there and they didn’t have a clue about what we’re trying to do.
  • there was no structure to where I was wanting to go with that training. So, if I was to start off a session and go with the first slide, I would go I don’t know where this is going.
  • I still think they’re top heavy with stats to start off with. To the point where I think it would bore people to death before they actually even got going unless you’re into that type of thing.
  • I think doing the basic living MECC conversation and trying to, for me, understanding what message I’m trying to get over and what I’m trying to impact on the MECC conversation. We didn’t really do a lot of that.
  • I did try and push it to start off with, then obviously when I was still in my old position it was just it wasn’t happening. It wasn’t happening. It was there was too much resistance so you just kind of hide away from it
  • and that would be, probably I would have said the majority of people that have tried to do the Train the Trainer.
  • So, I love that level, but then my boss did ask me to deliver one to HR and the proper MECC, core MECC. I froze because I looked at the slides and went, I don’t understand them.
  • So, I avoided doing that. I don’t think I was very popular. But it was causing me stress.
  • I never got it. Like I never got what they were trying to support you with.
  • The portal was very busy.
  • And I was never sure whether you could just pop into the forums, you could not pop into the forums.
  • I don’t have time to attend that Teams meeting that’s really nice to discuss these things because I just don’t have time to book my time out.
  • Yeah, there is the MECC portal, and you can log in and have a look. I got lost in it.
  • I haven’t been on the portal for months because I just got…I just looked at it and went this is way too confusing for me, so I just left.
  • I think in all honesty it’s evolving all the time that you almost feel you could get overwhelmed by how much information is going in there.
  • And I didn’t know who to ask as well.
  • Who might not get back to you or if they get back to you, they might not get quick at the question, or you might not feel comfortable speaking to them so you avoid them.
  • but again it’s that senior management don’t really get it
  • we pull people in with no expectation or understanding what the expectation is, and even my colleagues who went through the last sort of Train the Trainer they didn’t understand their expectations.
  • I mean, you sign up, there’s no you need to deliver four in a year, you know, this is your expectations.
  • but you see your physios, your allied health professions, they rotate, OK. They rotate through services.
  • Because as soon as you leave that, you’re going to go right, how do I do that. And then you get caught up in a lot of things.
  • Now, one of the things that we were aware of when I went on that is the managers didn’t know what it was. It might be different now a year down the line, so they were putting people forward just because they thought they were going to become aware of MECC.
  • You have everybody coming in and going you’ve got four hours, now you’re ready to do the training. How diluted and how messy is that training going to be?
  • If I was to say on an honest note, it was one of the worst training programmes I have ever been at because you didn’t, you came away bewildered.
  • The cascade part is proving quite difficult, I have to say.
  • I think the, yeah, I think the kind of practical kind of embedding and cascading can be quite difficult, so I think services and organisations are at different stages and I think sometimes as well they don’t see that actually what they’re doing all the time is MECC.
  • Which I suppose is a bit different to maybe some other people that are attending the Train the Trainer where they might not have that kind of either written into their job description or that opportunity to kind of channel that within their existing role
  • once it goes virtual you don’t have that level of interaction and you might have varied levels of interaction
  • I think my overall experience was at the end of it I thought right, how do I take this forward, and I did have to do a lot of work adapting it
  • So, I think, the difference I think is back then when I did it you did the Train the Trainer and then you kind of like were expected to kind of cascade it.
  • So, and I do feel that we’re not there yet with the signposting.
  • but I think where it falls kind of short a little bit is then cascading that within the team, but also building and embedding that in around kind of what resources we’ve got
  • so I talk about organisations building their own signposting toolbox that’s very specific to them. And I’ll give a little bit of a range of these are the things that you might want to look at or think of, but I never feel that that’s enough.
  • But sometimes that doesn’t translate to I don’t know if you’ve got somebody from a VCSE organisation it might not feel like it translates to them.
  • but then when a person leaves that session there’s still quite a lot of work to do to adapt it for them
  • kind of too left to the individual to then take it forward.
  • they almost felt a little bit I mean very unconfident in kind of delivering it
  • like it’s you’ve run through the training, you’ve got the slide deck, things like that, but it’s not your own kind of slide deck, so I think that person then has to make it their own
  • And I think then I suppose that’s the issue that comes back to kind of who is going to help that person with the support.
  • but for them to then cascade MECC as it is, as the standard core MECC, doesn’t fit with the (name of) programme.
  • if they just delivered standard MECC I think there would be a risk of people going well where’s the relevance to this for me
  • to maybes deliver that core training session to their team might be just a little bit too much but there might just be some kind of taster sessions that they can run in a team meeting
  • But I suppose thinking of maybe some of the other organisations that have done the train the trainer, they’re not necessarily trainers in their roles, so that’s probably a big issue as well.
  • but I think it’s the barrier’s maybe well how do I then deliver that within my team.
  • I think confidence is a lot of the problem. Possibly because I think if they’re thinking well, I’ve got to deliver that just how (name of principal trainer)’s delivered it, then that is going to be kind of a confidence issue.
  • So, yeah, I don’t know. I just wonder if it’s maybes too generic.
  • but then is that person in a position to kind of and has the capacity and the motivation to then watch that and think right, well I’m going to adapt that to kind of delivering my session.
  • But I think it always comes back to kind of effective signposting and I think that’s where we haven’t cracked it.
  • And maybes it doesn’t get seen as a priority
  • I suppose of a lot of people are doing the train the trainer they’re not doing anything with it afterwards, but they come back on the refresher training they’ll be thinking oh yeah, I really should do that and then do they do it when they leave the room again.
  • I think there’s definitely something that’s needed that then makes it actionable
  • it’s quite difficult as an outsider to be able to come up with a solution and say right well you just need to deliver MECC in your organisation in this way
  • However, the next day (circumstances) so I literally did the training and then boom was hit with a (circumstances) and everything that goes along with that. So, I had to kind of just shelve that.
  • So, kind of every day we’re practicing MECC as part of our job, so then part of my having not delivered any further MECC training from doing the Train the Trainer course I feel a bit like I would be teaching my colleagues what they’re doing every day, every minute of every day.
  • So, and to be fair time has been a huge factor because we’ve had loads of sickness in our team so we’ve been really short staffed.
  • I don’t think I’m a natural presenter and teacher
  • I think I would be apprehensive, one will my technology work, will this PowerPoint work and stuff, and two will my presentation skills be OK.
  • I think I would be apprehensive, one will my technology work, will this PowerPoint work and stuff, and two will my presentation skills be OK.
  • Unfortunately, within kind of 24 hours that all vanished because this is life, isn’t it? It throws these curve balls at you that you’re not expecting.
  • I didn’t have much time to actually acknowledge what I was doing until I was actually in the room and then (name of principal trainer) started to do the presentation and then I thought oh wowser, this is what I’ve signed up for.
  • There was one lady in particular, she was a very senior staff member who worked up, I think at (name of location), but she had people dotted around and she very much talked about the challenges of how she was going to deliver this training, cascade it to her team.
  • There was one lady, she was an occupational therapist who already was working above and beyond. In the eight hour shift she generally worked ten hours
  • Oh my God, this is another thing I’ve got to do and I’ve already got a jam packed schedule and I’m already working above and beyond and now I’ve got this to do.
  • And probably I was a little bit with that thinking oh my goodness, I’ve now got to deliver this as well, and I’ve got to deliver it to my peers who are already doing this.
  • I think probably within the first couple of minutes of after doing it you think oh, I can do this, this is really good, but then as time goes on your confidence does fade, it wanes away the less you have to do with it.
  • because there’s some really experienced members within my team, and then I think I got much less confident and thought, you know, it’s like teaching your granny how to suck eggs, like this doesn’t feel right, it’s what they’re doing day in and day out.
  • I have a bit of trouble retaining information so I kind of thought oh golly, how am I going to remember all of that
  • Because I’ve never asked the question and said look guys, I did this training in November, would you like me to present, you know, cascade the training to youse guys. Maybes I just need to do that because I’ve never done that.
  • so we’ve got our Panel tomorrow, no Thursday, and the work that’s gone into this has just been phenomenal so like I say, everybody is pretty stressed working really, really hard, so I would have to get my timing right
  • I would just do it on Teams because geographically I work (name of location) but our team covers (name of location) as well.
  • so I had it on my to do list and then it just kept getting pushed because I had also just completed and audit. So, I had to write my report for that as well as my workload and stuff.
  • I said to my manager I’ve done the train the trainer, the MECC Train the Trainer training, in November and haven’t done anything with that, but I’m not sure that I need to because I feel like the team do that day in day out and she just kind of agreed and said yeah, that’s fine
  • And part of us felt relieved that I had kind of been given the get-out-of-jail-free card.
  • But I think because her to do list is always so long, she’d forgot about it and there was kind of no expectation, you have to then present it within three months, six months or whatever.
  • so she quickly sends out an email, (AP8) will you do this, we need to tick a box, yes, I’ll do it. So that box is ticked. I’ve done the training, tick the box.
  • You know, you’re constantly getting this right, we need an infection control link nurse, who’s going to do it? Right, you do it, right fine, you attend their meetings and it’s just tick, that’s another job done. Because the work pressures are phenomenal.
  • I remember everybody in the room kind of everybody was like side eyes looking at each other like oh my God, what have we done.
  • But then to be fair I’ve not then had any more pressure
  • she was just like I’m so sorry. I’m sorry. I don’t need to follow this up anymore and kind of just moved on. So, that was the only little kind of bit of pressure from the trust.
  • And there was certainly no plan put in place from my department.
  • With regards to MECC, I think it’s a hard one because I think it’s time. It’s the time pressure when everybody is working so, so hard.
  • And again, we’re flying into winter now and already the hospitals are ramping it up getting busier and busier as well as trying to deal with waiting lists from COVID.
  • It’s the word extra, yeah, that is I think probably a bit of a barrier. And people don’t mean for it to be. If people really at the time think wow, this is great, and love the concept of it, it’s just in the real world that extra sometimes is just the extra bit you haven’t got time for.
  • because I think to do something like that and then have what happened the next day, trying to retain that, and it’s hard to try and go back to it, in my head.
  • So, I did the training, COVID kicked in and I never got around to delivering any
  • I sort of had a good background but even though it still wasn’t familiar and I felt still, and still do feel a little nervous beforehand, delivering the training
  • because we had in our group a lot of people from different organisations who hope to roll it out to their companies and it probably hasn’t happened. But one they weren’t trainers because they were really a bit nervous on the course like oh but what if I can’t answer the questions, you know.
  • The sort of things you do worry about even as a trainer, and they weren’t trainers, so I bet that puts people off a little bit.
  • I had a little bit of the background, but even then I had to keep looking back at the PowerPoint saying oh I need to know more about this
  • if they’re not, their job isn’t the trainer, I think it will be a bit difficult to suddenly go in, but the more you do it, the easier it gets, like everything, but if they only need to do it once or twice a year they’ll probably get quite nervous about it.
  • I have had groups where I just can’t get them going and nobody seems to interact
  • Just you think they’re being forced there by their manager, or they’re just not interested.
  • And it was a Monday morning, so I thought maybes it wasn’t the best time, and nobody seemed to interact, nobody wanted to talk, and they just listened, went, so that was a bit of a flat time.
  • I mean, I did feel I haven’t got (name of principal trainer)’s knowledge, but I think because he’s done it loads of times and it will come with time, yeah.
  • I didn’t like the ice cream van one. I don’t know whether you’ve seen it, there was an ice cream, and I can’t think what MECC, there was one of the behaviour change methods, I think it was prime, something like that. I found that hard to explain
  • I go to all these forums and still I find that hard to explain, but obviously we don’t always have time in our work life, do we, to go to everything that’s online.
  • I think a lot of people have changed their mind about teaching because they don’t want to do it online.
  • Confidence OK but I think you’re a bit weary about starting to do it yourself. It’s all right to let someone teach you it, but again a bit nervous about having to do it myself and having to brush up on a few things.
  • but it’s just the actual doing it, and I think like if people in that room, some of them like work for children services but they weren’t trainers. And I think I can imagine it being an even bigger thing for them, it’s just doing it.
  • I really feel for those who hadn’t trained before, it would have been quite a bit step for them to change.
  • I’m probably fitting it into a role that they’re already busy. It’s time for a lot of things, isn’t it, a capacity.
  • Or if you go to venues there’s always the IT issue. That’s always worrying for any trainer.
  • I do a lot in community halls as well, like organisations similar to mine, and that’s when I’d have to take probably a projector because not all of them have a projector.
  • Those cards with all the little prompt questions on, they were like a little card, I haven’t got them, but I think they will be useful. But I know it costs a lot to print.
  • It’s worth have another visit I think, and again I’d love to go to the meetings for the train the trainer, but I don’t often have the time.
  • I mean, at first, I struggled with the website
  • and sometimes we couldn’t get certificates, but I think that’s sorted now.
  • Just finding the time because I only work part time and I still find I do a lot at home for other things
  • but just again she sort of has other roles as well so it’s just occasional
  • So, I think you get this idea that trainers know everything, and they don’t, you know, they’re just human, and we do sometimes have to find out, go back and get back to people later
  • Yeah, yeah. Yeah, they’re worried they haven’t got the knowledge. They’re worried they’re going to get asked questions that they don’t know
  • And (name of principal trainer) was encouraging but obviously I just feel it’s the confidence thing with the ones who’ve never trained before.
  • I mean, I’m doing the train the trainer mental health and I’m a bit nervous of that because I don’t have a great knowledge of mental health.
  • A little bit because usually you get very positive comments, but I think one of the comments there was I wasn’t very enthusiastic, which I’ve never had that before
Facilitator 402 passages
  • I didn’t know from our end, from our organisation that the plan was to roll it out and train other members of staff
  • I think because of being trying to implement MECC for such a large time during the work, working environment, it just felt like a natural sort of progression. I felt quite comfortable at the idea of having to then deliver the training.
  • So, every week that I’m standing up delivering health lifestyle sessions and stuff like that and using the PowerPoints and stuff, so in that sense absolutely fine, it’s not something that’s completely new.
  • A lot of the team have to do very similar things with the programmes that they deliver on, so I think we’re all pretty confident about it and want to go ahead and do it.
  • I’ve done so much of MECC in the past and I’d been trying to implement it into my working role for such a long time that, and a lot of the team that I’m working with haven’t had as much or if any experience with MECC, so I thought it was just only the right and natural and the fair thing to do for me to say I’ll do the Train the Trainer.
  • I just thought if I’m on board with it then at least I can support them with delivery as well.
  • It was good because a lot of the team leads and the management actually they got involved as well. They came along to the core training themselves.
  • I think it’s really good that pretty much everything’s been done for you, so the slides are there, the PowerPoint slides are there. The resources are there, the handouts are there, everything’s there for you.
  • And we got sight of a few of those things in the training, so it was good to have that, and as I say, just some good advice on how to improve your delivery style if you like.
  • one of the things that we’ve been doing in terms of getting ready for delivery is having a lot of team meetings about how we’re going to implement it
  • I think it’s more motivating for people when they know that actually the work’s been done. We’ve provided everything for you, all we’re asking you to do is go out and deliver it.
  • if people haven’t had as much experience of delivering training, they probably took a lot more from it than what I did.
  • I think that’s largely down to the experiences I’ve had in the past.
  • if you don’t offer that session, you could potentially be letting people loose who think they’re capable of going and delivering it then they’re not actually delivering to a good enough standard.
  • we’ve asked all of the team leads in all the centres to give us the best times
  • we actually have some site closures in December, so we’re putting on sessions at every centre during those closures where the staff are free
  • So, we’ll have two people delivering each session.
  • So, we’ve had quite a few sessions together already to go through the presentations, the core training and we’ve got time booked in to practice the delivery.
  • we’ve invited members of the wider team to come along and be our guinea pigs while we deliver to them before we actually get to the actual delivery.
  • As I say, I’ve kind of found myself taking a bit more of a lead role on it because I probably do have the most experience with it. And it’s just making sure that everybody’s on the same page and up to the same sort of standard
  • It’s always been that everyone who did the Train the Trainer was always going to have an involvement in the delivery.
  • You’ve got to do so many sessions, so I think from an organisational point of view there would be no value in just letting people sit back and not deliver.
  • Well, I kind of I did run it past (name of regional MECC at scale coordinator) first to say look, is it going to be OK if I tweak this and tweak that
  • So, we have rejigged it a little bit just to make it a little bit more appropriate for the participants and do it in a format that we felt more comfortable delivering it in
  • Definitely the pre-populated PowerPoints. As much as we might have tweaked them a little bit it’s just it was a massive relief to then come away knowing that actually I don’t have to go away and do all of this myself.
  • There are some good resources on there as well which we will use, like the scenarios for role plays and stuff.
  • the little prompt cards we’re going to get printed out to give to everybody on the training
  • there’s things I’ve gone back to management with and said that we’re not really comfortable with this and we’d like to think of a different approach to do with this, and they’ve kind of just said OK whatever works for you.
  • He’s always been on hand quite quickly if there’s been any questions that I’ve had or any concerns.
  • I think they probably could have done with a little bit of time to reflect and digest and come away from the core MECC, have some conversations with other members of staff who’ve done it before, get a little bit more of a better understanding of MECC before going back to do the Train the Trainer.
  • I’m never one to turn down a bit of networking because you never know what benefits you’re going to get from it and how it’s going to potentially improve and benefit your own role.
  • So, because I normally did training roll out to (the team) my line manager was asked to go on the training and she asked me to go along with her.
  • so I was fairly comfortable that I had good relationships with (the teams), and I knew sort of kind of how to present them in a way that they would get along with.
  • Once I kind of understood what I’d be delivering and [07.51 unclear] and everything I was really excited to go out and do it. I was sort of ready and rearing to go straight away.
  • So, I had other training that I needed to deliver as well so in my mind I was like that’s great, the drill night’s three hours. I need an hour to do this so I’ve got two hours where I can do the MECC training
  • My boss was really good about making sure that we did a lot of health and wellbeing training, and we got access to all of those resources.
  • maybe a little bit of like presentation skills and like mock presentations or something, just focusing more on the presenting element rather than the MECC element.
  • But I would have been quite happy after getting the training just to go out and deliver it based on the resources available online and just editing them myself.
  • So, I liked the fact that they had different slides that you could sort of cut and paste in.
  • Oh, I was really confident. I would have done it the next week.
  • So, I’d already been having those conversations about how to draw this information out of people, so it felt like a familiar topic just with more resources behind me to help me out.
  • I think they had some good ideas about activities and stuff that you could do.
  • if we’d then had to do it again in a year or two years when the next sort of new cohort of (name of role) came through I probably could have done with a little bit of a touch up
  • But I liked the idea of it as well because then you might necessarily not need a refresher training if you could just link in with someone else and be like oh, can you just remind us about this bit again and how are you delivering these couple of slides
  • whereas I think we went in with GPs and the GP was just going to distribute it to their surgery and they were the MECC champion, they were going to roll it out to their surgery, they’ve got control over that process.
  • And you’re adding more and more barriers that are going to put them off, whereas if you link into stuff that they’ve already accepted this is within my realm of responsibility, it’s a lot easier to get them on board that way.
  • My big thing was I just wanted to get that app on all of the (redacted for confidentiality) and my thinking was if I can get that MECC app on there, even if they don’t listen to us when I’m training them
  • I think I would have had everything I needed, and I would have been happy to go out and deliver it based on what was accessible online and I was always getting the emails refreshing them as well, so things were quite up to date which was quite nice too.
  • Maybe some guides on like activities to do with them possibly because they love a sort of hands on task being a(name of role)
  • I’ve then got to give hours where they’ve got nothing else booked in it would have been quite nice just to be able to pop the MECC in those two hours.
  • but again thinking of some sort of non-IT based resources might have helped on that front
  • We have printers in all of the (name of buildings) and there’s no sort of regulation on if I’d be printing that off
  • it makes people feel more confident if they tweak the slides a little bit or they had their own activity that they were going to do, it felt like it was their training and then that made them feel a bit better delivering
  • so I had all the infrastructure there on actually booking it and arranging to go out, it was just I needed signoff before I could send the email saying we’ve got this training to deliver to you.
  • I quite liked it because I think for us the relationship with the (the teams)s was really important delivering training, so having that good relationship with them makes them more receptive
  • I had it with most of them and the ones that I didn’t have it with are the people they have it with, so we’d kind of swop around who went to each (team) depending on who knew that (team) better.
  • So, it was already conversations that were happening, so I didn’t feel like I needed to go in from scratch and start the MECC conversation with them which probably made things a bit easier for me.
  • and they were getting really excited about the changes they were making, and I think that would have linked in really well with MECC
  • So, I’ve done a couple of sessions already, so it is in my job role.
  • I’ve started to say actually if you want me to deliver your MECC training I’ll deliver it on the proviso that you have someone go on the train the trainer so that when you get new staff coming in you can train them, you don’t need me to come back.
  • So, we’ve used the MECC slides so it can be delivered digitally, and people can do it in their own time.
  • one girl’s really keen but she’s not delivered training before, so she’s got to come along with the couple that I’m doing
  • So, are they going to ask us something, well and my answer is well you don’t need to know the answers, that’s why the MECC Gateway’s there.
  • I enjoy, I’d bite their hand off if they want us to go train them.
  • I pop in a few examples of relating to practice.
  • Yeah, so I’ve got the video in and then I’ve added in like a group activity
  • Too many models of change. Just have one. One model of change. Just make it simple.
  • Or I leave the slide up, but I explain it in a different way to allow them to have…to allow them to understand but not make it overly complicated.
  • They value MECC. They understand the value of it
  • Yeah, I am probably pretty confident in doing training anyway.
  • So, I think my background really made it super easy for us to just transition.
  • I think it just reinforced all of the things that I already knew and gave us the backup of that there’s a gateway there. All of the information’s there for you.
  • so I had a little look on the Future NHS and there was low and behold the lovely new templates that had came out for the PowerPoint so we’re going to use them
  • It increases the uptake in MECC and gets them on board, but it also then provides this thought of extra resource for them.
  • So, I think that’s a good selling point to get them to do the core MECC and then top up with other training.
  • I think I’m passionate about it. I mean I’d make a good salesperson.
  • And I reach out to other services and say actually
  • So, can we train your staff, and I sell it as in we’re going to make them more resilient because they’re going to know what questions to ask and where to signpost to.
  • And with the condition that I train all the rest of the staff first. So, they’ll have seen us do it and then they’ll go onto the train the trainer, so it will be, you know, it should be easy enough.
  • We really need to get it onto sort of the newsletter or something like that, something that goes out to people.
  • you’ve got my email address, if you’re struggling, if you’re worried about anything come back to us about your training.
  • I’m chatty. I’m chatty. I’m gobby and I’ll be like well that’s lovely, but I need you to do this for me.
  • I think it’s that give and take. I think it’s got to be give and take.
  • People sometimes need some handholding and some understanding just to get it up and running.
  • Yeah, I mean I’ll just email them and ask if I need anything. So, I do go to the regional forum so it’s there if I need it.
  • we should look at the resources together and think how can we, you know, it should be a team effort
  • And a bit more understanding about the wider determinants because I feel like it’s if you don’t have that health background it’s skipped over a little.
  • So, it made it much easier to disseminate the training because you could offer it at times that suits your service in a way that suits your service.
  • Yes, I do, but how often I’m not sure about it. Or could the refresher be online?
  • A little update on this is what we’re seeing in the area that you’re working in. I think that would be really helpful
  • So, I think that peer support is fantastic. However, I think people are afraid to ask.
  • I think I’ve always like to, you know, I’m a person that can stand up and talk to people. I’m quite outgoing and stuff
  • But I had some really good sort of help with the girl who’s like the lead on MECC in our trust.
  • But obviously when I did it I took though out because it wasn’t really relevant to us
  • her sort of thing was the more you do it the more familiar you are with everything the more it becomes like a talk rather than I am reading off a piece of paper.
  • And that does give you all the information so even if you literally start the training and say go to the website, stop the training after you’ve done your bit, you know.
  • I learned how good it was to enable me to signpost people to it in my training
  • I’m still having an eight week induction, so I’ve got a little bit more time at the moment so I can do things like this
  • Yeah, they were really good actually. They were really good about it.
  • the trust does have quite a good push, big push towards physical health and health promotion because the NHS, you know, it’s part of the five year plan and all that sort of thing, so it was like well yes, as long as you’re going to use it kind of thing, and obviously I have done.
  • So, yeah, I think I’m now down as a trainer so if they need some training, you know, I mean we’ve already got one trainer, one very good trainer, you know, but she says it’s just nice to have some support, you know.
  • I think like with anything, you know, like the idea of training somebody else on it you need to be pretty sure of what you’re doing before you can, you know, teach it to others really, haven’t you? So, it’s kind of that consolidating it all and getting it right in your head
  • I rang her up straight away and says was it OK. She said yeah, that was really good
  • But on the other hand, I think as a trainer it’s easier online because you can have your notes in front of you
  • So, it was good to have (name), who’s our sort of link worker for that, because she gave me loads of tips and everything
  • but like she’s sort of like adapted it a bit more to us so it was virtually the same core but there was just a few bits that weren’t relevant
  • Had I not had her, it would have been probably a different experience
  • And because I literally I did the training to myself and sort of like so oh, that bit doesn’t read very well, oh I don’t like that bit, I don’t think that’s relevant, I don’t think we need that bit and stuff like that.
  • We have, we’re quite lucky with that, because we have a weekly CPD hour.
  • And originally, originally, she was going to deliver it and when I saw the work that she was doing I sort of messaged her and said we’re doing this, can I do this. She’s oh yes.
  • that’s a rolling programme, so we’ll probably put it on again next year and I’ll probably just do it next year
  • I mean, we have like well on the training there’s the Connect 5. I think that’s really relevant, especially to where we are in our service sort of thing.
  • Well, I mean to be honest I only found out about those from another training actually a few days ago, so I now would also direct people to that
  • because I mean as I say, if we hadn’t already got the system up for CPD it would be like trying to find a time, trying to find a place, trying to find a spot and trying to put it in the diaries
  • So, had we not had that slot already kind of pencilled in and had (name) not sort of given me the support she was, it would have been a lot more difficult.
  • So, had we not had that slot already kind of pencilled in and had (name) not sort of given me the support she was, it would have been a lot more difficult.
  • I am confident, that’s the word, isn’t it?
  • it’s like well I want to do this so I’m going to find a way of doing it, so it’s kind of yeah, determination I suppose.
  • I think so because it spurred me on to try and do something. I kind of came away from the training with like oh let’s do this, you know
  • Had the training actually not already been booked in then I probably would have contacted them and said can we put this into the bite size training.
  • So, yeah it did give me the impetus and the enthusiasm I suppose to go out and do something, I think, because yeah, I think it’s so relevant to what we do.
  • If it was like every year or every two years, I think that would be great because there are changes, there are things update.
  • the other part of my role was to develop or deliver the MECC program of work across the organization.
  • So, at the point in time where the train the trainer model was emerging, that was really positive for us because it just meant that we could adopt that cascade approach
  • some of it might have to happen in trust induction or on a pre-existing training programme, like we've got preceptorship and care certificate, health and well-being champions is another one that we've got and we weave MECC into those.
  • So they're, they're quite good because we've got a bit of a captive audience and quite high numbers.
  • So we, we took two of them out and just kept the stages of change.
  • So after the Train the trainer, we, what we did was we sent out, created a document, trust specific signposting that everybody gets.
  • and we ask staff if they, as part of signing up to the training they've got to deliver four core MECC sessions within a year.
  • So what we say is do your, do your half day training, try and book in your first core MECC within the first four weeks.
  • once a month we will have a bit of a, like it's an informal, it's just on teams, an informal session where anybody who's done that training can come along and share their experience of delivering the training
  • So we would club together and try and deliver some update training to our cohort of MECC trainers across that patch
  • So we do that as well and we'll always offer to co-facilitate if people aren't feeling massively confident.
  • So theyve decided that there would be a more targeted approach to the training, so we would work with engaged teams and say yes we’ll do your train the trainer.
  • The thing with sort term support service, they are actually the most engaged teams that I have come across in the whole organization because they're already flying with their own training they've got, across the locality they’ve got four or five people who are doing it routinely
  • we've done a lot of comms, we've done a lot of promotion. So there's no end of requests to be MECC trained
  • I mean in terms of the capacity within our team there is also a clinical educator who’s supporting this piece of work.
  • So because we're in the Community business unit, we, we've worked closely with the management team there and they decided they want 50% of staff within the Community to be trained in MECC.
  • So we have got a lady in the team who supports that.
  • whereas it's far easier just to say do your MECC training in a team meeting, take a paper register, scan it through to us and we'll update it on that staff members records.
  • So again, they are our conduits out to the junior doctors and medical staff so they will take that forward, and that won't be an issue because that's part of their work within the team
  • so their management team are coming along, they're quite keen, and then they will develop, they'll deliver Core MECC to their staff over time.
  • So at least if we're working in a more targeted way with these particular teams under phase two, then we've got a bit more leverage
  • so they were public health fellows with medical education, so they have to do that and it was part of their role
  • they didn't have to go and hunt for, you know, a training session or a group of staff because they were always training the junior doctors.
  • and so then she was MECC trained and would deliver on maternity education days. So that was inbuilt.
  • Then we had clinical educators who were MECC trained. And again, lots of opportunities within their role to deliver MECC
  • So wanted to do the MECC training in order to build up the hours of teaching and learning they needed for their qualification.
  • That might be one approach to encourage people, you know, if you’re doing your practice education or practice development qualifications then I guess deliverign MECC sessions routinely would I suppose tick a box for certain people.
  • were just really keen and invested and were just doing it. There was no need to nudge or do anything, they were just doing it.
  • And I don't know whether that's because they had, or they have a manager who is very interested and passionate about it
  • I think I would probably feel like I had to do something with it. Because why else have I spent half a day of my life doing it?
  • Whereas if your manager, if you’ve got a manager who’s saying come on, there's three or four of you from the team have gone off and spent half an hour, half an hour, half a day, doing your training, we need some movement on it.
  • I mean, our health coaches, they've all done MECC train the trainer, so they would, as part of their role they would be delivering on the care certificate or they might co-deliver a session.
  • So it's, yeah, it's probably the ones where there's opportunities within their job already to deliver education
  • and if they're part of the public health team as well, then the expectation is that they would be, they would be doing MECC routinely.
  • and I guess a lot of it is practice over time, isn't it?
  • if we reflect back on the slides then what are the areas where you feel you might struggle to present that, and how can we, you know, what are some of the key things that you could say
  • you have got to take a little bit of ownership about, you go away and you familiarize yourself with the content
  • But I think more, more influence or more information on how do you actually deliver this? That would be helpful.
  • Yeah, there’s a lot there that you can sort of link up to where you can say I think I would feel confident if I was doing something in that sphere.
  • And getting the confidence as well, because obviously when you’re doing sort of teaching sessions it can be quite daunting at times, but I think that helped as well.
  • I had a contact with a few of the people on the course, for instance, and it was actually a lady who used to work here, and she said do you want to do the course together.
  • I think two minds is better than one. And you can sort of work off each other
  • I think there should be a clear, very clearly identified structure, you know, initially anyway to get you from there, done the course, to actually doing some sessions
  • But it’s got to be followed up, I think. There’s got to be a structure where you say right, you’ve done that now how do you move on with the skills you’ve got and put that to good use.
  • I would have liked to have say like the follow up, right OK a couple, you know, whatever period after and say right, what have you done in that, have you done anything at all since we last met.
  • Yeah. I think with the right sort of input, and I think that’s possible as well, you can create the time because you’ve got to prioritise your time and say yeah, that needs to be a priority.
  • Yeah, the next step. What is it? What is it that you could offer me to say right well you’ve done that, is there anything that leads on from that.
  • Obviously just to keep in touch would be—
  • You look and say well we’ve invested in their training, what are they doing? What are they doing with that?
  • As I say, I would put more emphasis on after.
  • I think initially I would look for support, but once I think it had been done, I think then I will feel OK to do, set it up myself.
  • I think it’s once you’ve done it, I think that’s where you need to possibly look to target in on actually what the individual would be involved with or happy to be involved with.
  • I imagine some of them will because as I identified, they knew each other
  • In some, yeah, and just really to say well how are you doing, have you done anything, is there any help you want.
  • When you’ve got a teaching session your experience sort of gets you through.
  • I think that would be very helpful.
  • but it can be very, what can you say, very beneficial and cost effective, I think.
  • For instance, here I could say right, can we organise a free venue.
  • our director of public health was really keen to embed MECC within (name of location) Council and the city.
  • we’ve kind of got the basis of like the city-wide group and a few have done Train the Trainer and they’re starting to deliver it amongst organisations.
  • But I mean now we’ve got like more buy in from senior managers and they’re very keen to have MECC, so that’s where I’ve got the core MECC module.
  • And there was space, and my manager was really keen for me to do it, just with being the lead on MECC.
  • And I think it helps doing the core MECC first and then the Train the Trainer where you’re going over them core MECC slides.
  • Like until I’d done the session with (name of principal trainer), I would have been very nervous doing it.
  • So, there was me and someone from the finance team. We double teamed to do it because she had a finance background, I had the MECC background.
  • I do look at them regularly because we’ve got name of charity) who are commissioned to deliver it for two years.
  • I don’t know, something a bit more on that side, but again it’s I’m not from a training background so it might just be my insecurity of being a trainer. Maybe like a little bit more on the training.
  • So, now I do it in presentation kind of pointing and I’m moving
  • Like she’s very kind of open and confident and she is a trainer so I think she obviously wouldn’t struggle as much as I would.
  • I think the more I did it the more I would get used to it.
  • I feel more comfortable with someone else as well, like a co-host.
  • Or if it was people I knew maybe it might really get a little bit—
  • And it’s part of our public health plan that we want to get, and the wellbeing strategy that we want to get everyone at (name of location) Council kind of MECC trained.
  • I suppose I’ve got the advantage that I have read the slides quite a lot, so I am familiar with them.
  • Maybe it might have, in terms of delivery, it might have been better to separate them if we had the luxury of being able to do that.
  • Yeah, it’s really useful and I like the way there’s like a pick of videos.
  • Yeah, the sign in sheets, I’ve used that obviously in the core slides. Yeah, again I can’t fault the resources so.
  • but we’ve got a budget that she gets paid for, for doing that.
  • And you get paid per course so.
  • If there’s ever an issue, I just send (name of regional MECC at scale coordinator) an email and he’s pretty quick.
  • So, I just feel having support of the regional team which perhaps wasn’t as good before (name of regional MECC at scale coordinator) and (name of principal trainer) joined.
  • and I think the regional group’s probably helping everyone kind of get the same level or catch up a bit.
  • We’ve always kind of made it explicit that you’re expected to if you do it
  • I mean I’d suggest if they wanted to like co-facilitate it with someone else we could link them up.
  • But yeah, maybe just I don’t know, maybe just reiterate it, you know, you are expected to deliver.
  • Just so they know they’re on track.
  • I think it would be useful, yeah. Definitely. And definitely for the ones who haven’t delivered yet.
  • but maybe sort of more of an open session on anything you’re struggling with.
  • And there was a few questions that I had, and it’s just clarifying them before you start training, because it is new.
  • Like I said, we’ve got the internal task and finish group now, so they’re really keen to deliver MECC within a lot of the council staff.
  • I think I already had a strong motivation to deliver it because historically I’m aware of the impact that it can have.
  • she came back to me, and she said (AP4), I’m sorry, I really wasn’t getting this.
  • I think there needs to be some perhaps very clear communication but the idea behind Train the Trainer isn’t that it’s going to take a huge chunk of your job and your time, it’s about you delivering a few courses every year and about the spread
  • So, maybe there needs to be different offers, you know. There maybe needs to be an offer of find your nearest MECC training to update yourself or maybe another option would be can you then share that with some other people and come and do the Train the Trainer training.
  • Not for me, because my own work’s fairly well self-directed
  • for people who maybe are in more structured roles where they’re not self-directed maybe that would help.
  • So, I think a how to guide would really help. A step-by-step this is what you need to do to get your first session going
  • So, I think a little bit of information in that how to guide are what you need to find to put in the presentation just to make it clear.
  • And I can’t learn by watching a video. I think you need to have something written as well.
  • I’ve got a post graduate certificate in adult education so I’m a little bit more confident in delivering
  • I do a lot of presentations in my current work, so whilst there may not be training as such, I’m quite comfortable in that situation.
  • but I think with a clear step-by-step guide that could be overcome.
  • So, I think you’ve got to make the case studies relevant to your setting and I think there are a lot on the Futures platform that cancer specific I think would be helpful.
  • Totally supportive of me delivering it and I can’t really say more than that, you know.
  • It’s something that I talk about in management meetings, it’s something that I talk about in team meetings. They’re happy for me to promote it, to plug it.
  • Could you do some fun things, some incentives for people who’ve delivered the most courses or like a leaderboard or something like that.
  • I’m going to a MECC trainer’s brunch which I think is a great idea on Tuesday next week with (name of location) Council, so I think was part of their plan to ensure that it’s rolled out.
  • I just think the way it’s organised could be clearer so you’ve got this is what you need to do, this is the generic module, everything you need to deliver your first session is in this folder.
  • so I think this will be who maybe doesn’t necessarily have the time for that, they just need it one place
  • So, a quick link in the folder of delivering your first course. Step 1, you know, make sure you register the course here
  • But I think a PDF poster that you can put your trust’s logo on and put the date and time in and you can then send out rather than it just being all text.
  • So, yeah, I will make sure that that is a resource that I suggest everybody uses when they come to the MECC training
  • So, maybe being clear that you don’t have to have previous training experience to deliver it.
  • maybe buddying people up with somebody who is delivering it that they can go to for advice
  • actually it might have been really good to have had a buddy to say actually where the heck do we find this stuff
  • I mean I do get that the buddy to deliver it would be helpful. That would instil a lot of confidence as well.
  • For me, personally, I like to see what I’m going to deliver so I think you need to see what you’re going to deliver, see the course being delivered by someone.
  • Two hours most but I think that would be a good idea and a good way to instil confidence and give people a boost.
  • I’m looking forward to going to see who else is delivering in my local area and to see what their approach is, who they’re targeting, how they’re doing it.
  • I probably wouldn’t be able to find the time easily to travel say an hour in each direction to do that, but it’s on my doorstep so I think very local ones would work
  • We know the population, we know the demographics, you know, we know the challenges.
  • it might be because I work with clinical people who like their evidence, I’d like to see some evidence included in MECC about its efficacy, how effective it is.
  • The main thing that was in my mind that I’d thought of before the interview was just making it easier for people to have that step-by-step guide and all the resources in one place for the core training
  • But I used to deliver other training. I used to do brief advice or the IBA, alcohol, identification and brief advice for alcohol while I was at Northumbria Healthcare.
  • So, I think having that kind of community of trainers that come together and where they can talk to each other, but also link up with each other and perhaps co deliver.
  • Or I mean ideally, they could ask each other to co-facilitate with each other and support each other and buddy
  • But it definitely would have, I think helped to have a buddy to deliver it.
  • So, if I just put a bit of an actress kind of actor kind of thing on there’s a performance. It doesn’t feel as intimidating
  • It’s not always that way and actually sometimes I’ve been quite surprised that people have been so receptive and gone actually this is really helpful.
  • and our regional website has sort of 28 different or 30 or something different topic areas listed on there and that’s helpful and I definitely think without that we’d be a bit lost
  • I suppose feeling a bit better about delivering it because I knew that she, my ex-colleague, was delivering it as well.
  • So, that’s definitely been a factor although now I feel like in the last year MECC has just been better received by people.
  • so my line manager said get in touch with (name of regional MECC at scale coordinator), get in touch with (name of principal trainer), you need if you’re taking the lead on MECC, you need to organise some training sessions.
  • So, when we came back my line manager said we need to set up some sessions, we need to get them rolling so that the research can be done around them.
  • But actually, it was really beneficial for me to listen to it again because it had been a couple of years since I’d done it as well so the resources had changed
  • I mean we have obviously tweaked it for our own organisation but at least you know you’re kind of working to a bit of a template around that. So, it was very easy to access and very easy to organise sessions for our staff.
  • My line manager is absolutely definitely on board with MECC.
  • she said that she gets the MECC stuff, she sees its importance as well.
  • I have delivered MECC presentations a couple of times to there and I think that just helps to get the message out
  • MECC is something I often talk about and I often even I’ve delivered MECC at some of those meetings as well.
  • also the MECC Gateway website which wasn’t there before. I think that really helps because you can signpost people to that
  • We’ve had actually quite a few staff teams have come and said can you come and do, we want this for all our staff, can you come do this staff training on such and such date.
  • I don’t know whether it’s just me sending emails and being a bit tenacious
  • I suppose the benefit of online training is that you can do that. Obviously, we’d never have a venue that was available to deliver to 200 people
  • so I’m kind of trying to integrate that, or infiltrate, the training days so that we can actually get in to speak to people right at the beginning of their careers.
  • In order for me to deliver it I was there to really observe and shadow and that’s why I wanted to go to every session he delivered because it helped me to kind of ingrain that into my mind as to what I would say.
  • And I think the Train the Trainer bit on the end was really useful because I think people aren’t necessarily natural trainers.
  • You know, the practicalities of delivering a session, promoting it, bookings, registers, IT facilities and kind of it’s a bit more of a full package rather than just leaving people to it
  • And so, I think that’s been helpful because it highlights to people that in our trust that it is really about them, for them, and it’s really relevant to our service users
  • Staff were just, when we had conversations about it staff were just saying can we do it in two hours, can we do it in an hour. It would be much easier to release staff
  • I think I’ve shortened it because I had to, but then also as a result of that I took out the things that I didn’t feel as comfortable delivering.
  • But because working public health it’s my job to deliver that training, so I have time set aside to do that
  • I have the time to set up the app, I have the time to evaluate and go and look at the sessions.
  • So, feeling more comfortable in delivering the MECC training comes from me having the time to look at the training slides
  • and she contacted me and asked me if I would be happy to kind of spend some time with her going through the training stuff
  • she said can I joint deliver that with you so it gives me the opportunity to kind of have a go without feeling like I’m thrown into the deep end.
  • I’ve offered the support to deliver it, I’ve offered the kind of shadowing, the cofacilitating, tried to make it as easy for them to do as possible.
  • some of the sessions I actually set up sessions and said does anybody want to deliver this, all you need to do is log on and present it for an hour and a half, everything else is taken care of.
  • And booking, the booking system and things. So, maybe that would be helpful
  • It just needs you to find the right individuals.
  • I don’t know whether there potentially needs to be some interaction with the individual’s manager to say if your staff member is coming on this training there is an expectation that they deliver X number of sessions in a year
  • In your role you will be allowed, or you will be expected and therefore given the time to deliver this number, a session, one session a year, two sessions a year
  • If they’ve got the manual, it’s almost like a safety net, they’ve got the manual there that they can take to a training session with them
  • so it’s easy enough for me to say don’t worry about going on there, I’ll send you the slides that I’ve adapted for (name of NHS trust) anyway.
  • So yeah, I think people possibly would benefit from just being spoon fed a bit more, especially when it’s not their role
  • But if I go back to when now that I’m delivery it to the care certificate people who haven’t had that experience, who aren’t embedded in the service, who are not confident speaking to patients, that’s a really good way of getting them motivated and understanding and confident and also giving them permission to have that conversation.
  • If they’re starting the job, the induction part, MECC should be your induction part.
  • In the hospital I’ve done a lot of education groups with patients so that didn’t faze me about delivering something when I understood what I was trying to deliver.
  • And I think then when you realise that you’re embedded then you’re ready for the Train the Trainer or whatever we’re going to rename it because Train the Trainer is terrible.
  • And that, if you get somebody to be a MECC ambassador you’re also getting them to be very motivated to lead from the front.
  • Then those people that love MECC and then become champions will want to go to Train the Trainer.
  • The only way you can really impact it is if they have a team meeting and you’re invited along to.
  • Oh, again, in this role absolutely because it’s part of my role.
  • And that is where you’ll find people that are passionate about delivering and not really care about the money.
  • But that’s my own passion of always being passionate about delivering that type of thing.
  • So, maybe to help with the MECC training, a MECC kind of payment should be given as well.
  • Because it’s a massive thing. You know, put that on your CV oh you’re going to get the next job.
  • We’ll give you a £50 bonus every time you deliver it. People would be delivering it.
  • Whereas now I understand what I’m trying to deliver.
  • It’s very basic because in a sense from my clinical understanding knowledge, it’s that’s where I’m at.
  • Then coming into public health, there was an expectation that you delivered some type
  • so once I saw it delivered at care certificate level and what we’re delivering, I embraced that.
  • it wasn’t then I felt there needed to be a trust MECC where we just felt quite safe and you could just go in
  • But a MECC pack would have been really good.
  • With stuff that you could then go to your first training session and feel quite comfortable in it. So, prompt cards.
  • I think I’m lucky enough at the moment I’ve got like my support for MECC is very verbal because it’s part of my team.
  • And if you want to be a trainer you can access this to really help with your training delivery of it.
  • they need to go to the local advocate rather than one person who is covering a massive area.
  • So, from that side of things it’s massively supported. So, I’m lucky enough to have said it’s massively supported.
  • So, I think the Train the Trainer model is the last bit of training that somebody should do on MECC.
  • so Train the Trainer model should only be delivered to people that are really ambitious and aware and want to deliver MECC to other people
  • you almost have to make MECC trainers a different job role.
  • Become a MECC trainer. Boom. Understand it.
  • I think initially they need to be pre aware of what expectations there are so when they come out of Train the Trainer, they have a plan.
  • But actually, if you have somebody with a plan coming out and saying it’s already been discussed, this is where we’re going to go with it, and I want to deliver this, this and this and I’ve actually already emailed people.
  • So yeah, if whoever goes on the training needs to have had a discussion with the manager on how they’re going to deliver it before they go on the training.
  • So, I think it’s that, if you want to do that you need to have pre-permission from your manager to deliver it to a certain level and this will be done within the three months.
  • I think hundred per cent maybe once a year you get everybody in a year down the line, how’s things going and then just go through what’s new in MECC, what the stats are, how we’re doing with it and just have that support structure.
  • I think you need to have an internal resource support mechanism so again if you have your champions they can all share within a portal
  • The training that I deliver tends to be online but then I’ve got colleagues who do deliver face to face and deliver more bespoke, so we approach it as a bit of team.
  • But they have delivered their training with MECC as the overarching framework so it’s all about MECC conversations around health weight, MECC conversations around mental health
  • It was part of my job description as well, so I knew that that was this deliverable that had to kind of be delivered on.
  • there’s people in the team who are delivering on MECC, so I suppose there is that kind of that strengthens things, doesn’t it, kind of that they know that they want to kind of deliver on MECC within the joint health and wellbeing strategy
  • I delivered a face-to-face MECC session with a community organisation that worked really well just because the participants knew each other, they had a kind of a regular meeting place.
  • it works really well in (name of location) because the travelling to different venues is a massive kind of issue for people’s time and capacity
  • and I did have to do a lot of work adapting it and making it comfortable for me to deliver, making it (name of location) specific.
  • The structure now is that you’ve got the platform, the NHS Futures platform. You’ve got all the resources on there.
  • (name of principal trainer) and (name of regional MECC at scale coordinator) are very accessible for any support or advice on anything.
  • There’s a whole load of resources on the platform, not only just the core slides to deliver on but all the kind of different add on slides and things like that. So, it equips people more to be able to cascade it.
  • I think the strength that comes from a forum of trainer is really helpful. I think the stuff that happens after the training, like (name of regional MECC at scale coordinator)’s regional steering group, like (name of regional MECC at scale coordinator)’s regional trainer forum, I think some of the conversations that come from that afterwards are really valuable to be able to drive MECC forward in all the different localities
  • Maybes fire and rescue services from across the region would benefit from a very kind of fire and rescue focused MECC session
  • I think they definitely need some support afterwards
  • I suppose it’s like an implementation plan outline to kind of work through right, this is what I’ve learnt, this is what I’m going to do, so that it’s almost like a little bit of a plan of action
  • But I think maybe they just need some help to kind of adapt the slides and adapt the training and have that individual signposting toolkit that kind of fits it all together.
  • but there might just be some kind of taster sessions that they can run in a team meeting for example, like a ten minute slot of kind of this is what MECC is
  • So, maybes it’s more around rather than cascading training, maybes it’s around equipping people to having facilitated conversations.
  • has developed one of her training sessions with the MECC framework and to me, it’s just brilliant.
  • the family hubs have really kind of picked it up and worked with it. They had management who already had had experience of MECC in the trust, so I think that definitely helped.
  • Maybe, yeah, maybes leadership is something to do with it to help to kind of develop that vision
  • Again, I mean I suppose within our own team within the health improvement practitioners there was an expectation there that that was what the intention was, that they needed to kind of develop their training to like rework it around the MECC framework. There was that expectation that everybody was going to do that, so it wasn’t really optional
  • the health improvement team, myself, we do deliver training, that is part of our role.
  • so when the trainers have done the train the trainer I’ve kind of said well I can share some of the (name of location) signposting that I’ve got which will help you with your sessions, which I have done, but maybe that isn’t enough.
  • maybe that they need to reshape that MECC training around oral health, they need to know where all the signposting is, they need to know some of the facts and figures
  • but I think it’s about understanding what MECC is in your organisation
  • Looking at developing that signposting tool, knowing where to refer people to and then building it around that.
  • It’s slightly different because we’re training, yeah.
  • if we in (name of location) had a really effective way of signposting for MECC, then I think that would ultimately kind of move things forward a little bit because I think you’d have organisations that if you had almost like a ready made kind of thing
  • Or kind of working with individual organisations to kind of support MECC to be embedded and cascaded.
  • I suppose it doesn’t help people with the adaption and cascading. It brings it back on the agenda.
  • It helps me when I’m kind of linking with other local authority MECC leads, or MECC leads in different organisations. It helps me because quite often we’ve got the same challenges or we’re having the same experiences.
  • I think it has to be some maybe action focused support of actually this is what we’re looking to do, how are we going to do it and then everyone has like an action at the end of it of how they’re going to deliver on that.
  • so I think that’s when probably there’s a little bit more input needed with organisation around right, let’s get this to kind of work and let’s get this in place and get it in motion.
  • But then I try to kind of flip that the other day thinking but is that right, because should I still not do it and say I know youse are all experts in this, but just kind of highlighting the resources that are out there as well.
  • I don’t think I’m a natural presenter and teacher so and to be fair to (name of principal trainer), who did the training, did say we appreciate that this is, you know, difficult for people and stuff and that, but I was aware there was a lot of support there as well.
  • I think at that stage my motivation was quite high and really our team morale was quite low, and I did think oh this could be a good thing to help kind of boost team morale.
  • I joined the NHS is it the Future NHS forum, then it’s just whatever it is where you can log in and all the information is there.
  • so I know that if I was going to deliver it, if I’d got in touch with (name of regional MECC at scale coordinator), (name of principal trainer) that they would signpost us a hundred per cent in the right direction.
  • But I did think really supportive. I felt like if I needed support, it was there.
  • Obviously, you could do it, having support groups where it would be say for (name of organisation) staff who’ve done the training and then hopefully you could get together in a room
  • Yeah, the resources that are there, I think, are really good, and then each Monday morning I have a kind of email update of what’s been going on, on the forum and stuff, so if there’s been any changes or people are asking where slides are and stuff the support all seems to be there.
  • Literally it’s huge, so Teams would be the best way to do the training.
  • And I would think I would have to acknowledge their expertise and acknowledge that they’re doing this day in and day out.
  • I think I would probably reach out to (name of principal trainer) or (name of regional MECC at scale coordinator) and just ask for some guidance and help to make sure I was delivering it correctly.
  • He kind of gave us tips so said don’t just go in cold turkey, you need to practice with family or whatever. You need to time yourself.
  • Like if you did the train the trainer and then say right, like have another session where you did actually like develop a little PowerPoint. I don’t know, even just three or four slides and say right, you’ve been with this group before. Right, let’s practice your presentation skills and have some feedback from that type thing.
  • If she had said well actually (AP8), I think the team could benefit from it, I think it’s something I would like you to do, let’s make some time, let’s subdivide the team into however many groups and give it a go type thing.
  • so it was kind of engrained within your work and the workbook was always there on the table, and you witnessed her do it you signed and what went right and stuff, so I think it was just so easy
  • I don’t know, maybes it’s managers need to understand more that time needs to be given to the trainers to cascade the information.
  • I think for me personally, to be perfectly honest with you Beth, I think I could do the full training again. Train the Trainer that half day
  • if you then got the chance to be in a peer support kind of group afterwards and say right, did you manage to do it, how did you overcome these obstacles, how did you have the time, etc. etc. I think that would be brilliant. It would be really good and quite motivational.
  • So, me and a colleague went to do the train the trainer session and then we applied for the bid from (name of location) Council to actually go and deliver the training and we won the bid so we’re delivering it.
  • And it’s a little income for our company to sort of keep us going, so although we’re a (type of) organisation in our centre, we do outside training as well, so keeps sort of money coming in to keep the centre going.
  • and then I thought it’s going to start again so I did a refresh train the training with (name of regional MECC at scale coordinator) and (name of principal trainer), I think it is.
  • I was keen because I thought this is going to be something quite big, because MECC seems to underpin everything at the moment, so I was keen yeah to find out what it was about and how we were going to deliver it.
  • I found that hard to explain but I’ve noticed they’ve taken that out and they’ve left the one slide and the one with stool on the ladder, the COM-B one. I think they’re much easier to explain.
  • But with the MECC it’s the logistics are quite defined. There’s not a lot to carry. Yeah, not a lot of paperwork.
  • And once you’ve done it a few times, like everything it does get easier.
  • No, because (name of principal trainer) was relaxed. He really told us what to do if this happens, what to do
  • It was very clear, and it was really encouraging telling us to, you know, you will be all right, you will be able to do it.
  • Yeah. Yeah. Because I’m already either a tutor in (name of organisation) in the centre, or a trainer doing outreach things.
  • Oh, they were really keen. They were really keen because they knew, I think, they were forward thinking and they knew it’s something that we’re going to hear a lot of in the future
  • I think having the background sort of in that area in public health, in health promotion.
  • (name), I think you spoke to (name), she’s quite, she does the recruitment so she makes sure we’ve got people on the courses
  • and then everyone who seems to come like nine times out of ten are very keen and really want to do it with, and a lot of them are volunteers for (name of location) health champions, they’re not like people who work in different jobs.
  • It just covered everything you needed and then you can adapt it slightly if you need to add a few slides or take a few slides out, yeah.
  • but I do have a good relationship with (name), so she kept saying, you know, put in for it, so we had to apply.
  • No. Like (name)’s good that does the organising. I give her some dates I’m free, she’ll advertise it and then obviously we just go from there.
  • Well, I’ve got the basic PowerPoint. That’s all I usually need.
  • And the bus, you know the bus journey that they have, that’s useful. I use that quite a lot
  • And if I’m struggling, I just get in touch with (name of regional MECC at scale coordinator).
  • but (name) does most of the booking on so I’m not really involved with that side, which I was pleased because that would have took a lot of time
  • Yeah, it would be helpful to see, and especially when I realised the other people didn’t seem to like the ice cream thing neither. You know, you think it’s only you
  • Give it a go and even better if some of them like might have sent two in their organisation, and if you do it as a pair it’s always easier because one can chip in what the other one’s missed.
  • And I still have my days where I’m not confident and my colleague sometimes will deliver with me
  • it's not nothing to worry about and you can always get back to people if you don’t know the answer.
  • It’s nothing to worry about, it’s only half a day so I quite enjoy it.
  • I don’t know, just maybe stress that they could do it as a pair, you know, rather people maybes think they have to do this on my own
  • So, but I’ll try it and then I’ll probably pass it on to (name of organisation) where I work, probably do a practice run teaching some of the women there
  • Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, that is a good idea. I never thought of that. Another maybes after six month or something if they want to come on a refresher.
  • And if [29.15 unclear] organisation gives them the time, you know, I know places don’t always, to go on the refresher sessions and then give it a go

Grouping labels: Label

The label column of Coding: Label: 808 distinct labels on 809 passages, drawn into 20 items, and each passage given the item its label is listed under.

ItemMeansCountsDoes not count
Time and workload
Time and workload capacity to deliver
Whether the attender (or the people around them) had the time and capacity, beside their other work, to prepare and deliver MECC training.No time, high workload, short staffing, competing duties, delivery as an add-on to a busy job, an organisation too busy; or, as a facilitator, time set aside, an induction period with spare time, added capacity.Trainees (the staff to be trained) not being released or too busy to attend sessions (goes to Getting an audience); Delivery being formally part of the job, with or without time (goes to Job role); No time to attend the trainers' forum or support sessions (goes to Support networks)
Open labels it gathers (45)

cascading added a massive amount to workload, no time to read MECC email updates, organisation very busy so nothing likely to have happened, time to go out and staff shortage, having an in-house trainer takes extra additional time, train the trainer seen as an arduous additional responsibility, predecessor saw MECC delivery as a massive amount of work, induction period in a new role gives a little more time, a full caseload would make fitting anything in really difficult, patient work and staff sickness take priority, too busy, unsustainable for one or two people to deliver all the training, no capacity back in the team, public health team lacks capacity to deliver at scale itself, clinical educator adds capacity, teams already very busy, little leverage, lack of time, own and other people's, busy centre and busy project manager to liaise with, busy with other commitments (election agent), competing trustee duties, no capacity to deliver monthly herself, capacity issues in partner organisations, lack of capacity, backlog of more pressing work on return delayed delivery, trained trainers haven't got the capacity anymore, practitioners with a day job found it hard to prioritise MECC, trained trainers say they haven't the capacity to deliver, clinical staff trainers deliver only once or twice alongside their role, time to look at slides and resources builds comfort delivering, those doing it as an add-on lack time to prepare, life takes over after intending to deliver, being given the time in role to deliver, no time given to deliver in previous role, preparation time needed on top of delivery, get caught up in other things after leaving, no time because team short staffed through sickness, already working above and beyond, no spare hours, cascading seen as another thing on a jam packed schedule, delivering felt like an extra task on top of her work, service inspection (Panel) workload and team stress, kept getting pushed back by audit report and workload, time pressure when everybody is working so hard, winter pressures and COVID waiting lists, MECC training is something extra there is no time for, fitting it into already busy roles, no time or capacity, organisation giving them time to attend refreshers and deliver

Job role
Delivering training is (or is not) part of the attender's job role and remit
Whether delivering MECC training fits the attender's job description, role or remit, so that it is their work rather than an extra.Delivery in the job description or role; a public health or educator role that expects delivery; a remit too narrow to deliver widely; delivery seen as someone else's job; MECC's relevance to the service's work.Not having time within the role (goes to Time and workload); A manager setting or not setting an expectation to deliver (goes to Line manager)
Open labels it gathers (34)

already did training roll-out to the teams as part of her role, GP attender had control over roll-out in their surgery, delivering MECC training is part of my job role, trained colleagues pass delivery requests back to the lead trainer, colleagues see MECC delivery as the health-background lead’s job, further delivery depends on whether her job role allows it, delivering MECC is part of her public health role, delivery is part of public health fellows' work, management team trained as trainers to deliver to their own staff, delivery part of their role, opportunities within educator role, health coaches deliver as part of role or co-deliver, opportunities within their job to deliver education, expectation in the public health team to deliver, role is coordinating trainers rather than delivering, remit limited to staff working with cancer patients, so cannot deliver trust-wide, delivering MECC training not a core part of her job, so other work came first, self-directed role lets her choose to deliver, having delivery in the job plan would help those in structured roles, delivering is part of her job, with time set aside, other attenders not in a role that includes delivering training, delivering not in their remit or seen as relevant to their role, travelling to deliver at other sites is beyond his role, public health content outside my remit, delivering training is part of current public health role, new public health role expected delivery, make MECC trainer a dedicated job role, delivering MECC training was in my job description, other attenders lack delivery in job description or role, health improvement team expected to rework training around MECC, delivering training is part of our role, attenders from other organisations are not trainers in their roles, cascade engrained within daily work (as in her earlier cannulation TtT), training already part of her role

Line manager
Line manager backing, expectation and sign-off
What the attender's line manager or immediate management did about their delivery: support, setting an expectation, releasing time, sign-off, or the lack of these.Supportive or unsupportive managers; managers asking or not asking them to deliver; agreement before attending; sign-off delayed; being let off delivering; managers releasing or refusing time for the trainer.Senior leadership, strategies and implementation plans (goes to Organisational priority); Managers not releasing their staff to attend as trainees (goes to Getting an audience)
Open labels it gathers (30)

team leads and management took part in the training themselves, management support and flexibility on approach, boss supportive of health and wellbeing training, could not get sign-off from line management, line manager's massive workload doing two jobs, needed sign-off before she could book the training, bottleneck in the approval process, management worried about the amount of time delivery will take, supportive leadership and management, not supported to deliver back in the workplace, manager not supportive of the extra time, manager interested and passionate about MECC, manager not supporting delivery, manager pushing for movement on it, manager keen for her to do TtT as MECC lead, line manager came round after hearing the regional coordinator's presentation, management totally supportive of her delivering, line manager gave her the MECC lead and told her to organise sessions, line manager on board with MECC, line manager agreement that attender is expected to deliver a number of sessions, peers and management showed no interest, managers in clinical settings won't release team time for MECC training, my manager refused time to speak to her team, discussion with manager on delivery before attending, pre-permission from manager with three-month delivery timescale, family hubs management had prior MECC experience, manager agreed at appraisal she need not deliver, no expectation or deadline from her busy manager, manager asking her to deliver and making time would have helped, managers giving trainers time to cascade

Organisational priority
Organisational priority, plans and processes
Whether the attender's organisation (beyond the line manager) made MECC a priority and had plans and processes that enabled delivery.Senior leadership buy-in or its absence; strategies and implementation plans; MECC being or not being mandatory; box-ticking; red tape and approval processes; organisations preferring an outside trainer to an in-house one; the bespoke-slides process that held up AP10.The line manager's own support or sign-off (goes to Line manager); Funding or commissioning of delivery (goes to Pay and incentives)
Open labels it gathers (43)

organisation planned to roll MECC training out to other staff, waiting for bespoke slides that took forever, bespoke slides still not prepared when she left, focus on making it perfect rather than getting it done, wrapped up in red tape, decision on slides not shared with her, then delayed, partner organisation's MECC team too busy, slides took a long while, hierarchical organisation, blockage above you, no implementation plan in place, no point using forum resources while waiting on others' slides, cost-saving reapproval of every post slows recruitment, services reluctant to put staff on train the trainer, services want an outside trainer to train them all rather than disseminate it themselves, making her training conditional on the service sending someone on train the trainer, GP practices not keen to sign anyone up as trainer, want training done for them, practices don’t want to take on the responsibility of training, organisations see MECC as a tick-box blanket training rather than building in-house trainers, leadership value MECC, people not seeing the value of MECC, MECC training not mandatory, trust drive on physical health and expectation she would use the training, MECC hard to get up people's agenda as a priority, TtT model let the team adopt a cascade approach, lack of organisational buy-in to support trained staff to deliver, management target of 50% of staff trained, no MECC steering group or project plan, director of public health keen to embed MECC, buy-in from senior managers, MECC training in public health plan and wellbeing strategy, internal MECC task and finish group keen to deliver, research project already set in motion needed sessions running, senior manager (deputy director) sees MECC's importance, MECC message not yet cascaded across senior managers, unrealistic expectation of how many staff would be trained, public health implementation plan gives massive support, senior management in services don't get MECC, leadership commitment to MECC in the joint health and wellbeing strategy, leadership developing the vision, MECC not seen as a priority, attending the TtT treated as ticking a box, box-ticking culture under phenomenal work pressures in the NHS, no departmental plan for delivering, leadership keen and supportive of her becoming a trainer

Pay and incentives
Pay, funding, contracts and other incentives for delivering
Whether delivering brought reward or funding: a commissioning contract or budget, payment, career benefit, qualifications, or its absence.Winning a commissioning bid; income for the organisation; budget for materials; pay per course; no reward or extra pay; suggested bonuses, leaderboards or links to qualifications.Intrinsic motivation or passion (goes to Personal motivation)
Open labels it gathers (15)

delivering builds teaching hours for a qualification, linking delivery to qualification requirements would encourage people, charity commissioned to deliver core MECC for two years, budget to pay for materials, commissioned trainer paid per course, incentives or leaderboard for trainers who deliver most courses, no extra pay for the higher remit of delivering training, I get no reward or career progression for delivering, no incentive: people ask why should I do it, a MECC payment for delivering would help, career benefit of delivering MECC for higher-band staff, £50 bonus per session delivered would get people delivering, won a council commissioning bid to deliver the training, delivery brings income to keep her organisation going, good relationship with council contact who encouraged the bid

Personal motivation
The attender's own motivation and drive
The attender's (or others') own wish, passion, keenness or determination to deliver, or its loss.Being passionate, keen, excited, determined or tenacious; feeling an obligation; losing motivation; relief at being let off; delivering not being what they want to do.Confidence or experience as a trainer (goes to Trainer confidence); Coming to TtT without meaning to become a trainer (goes to Knowing delivery was expected)
Open labels it gathers (20)

excited and ready to deliver straight away, enjoys going out to deliver the training, passionate about MECC and a good salesperson, being chatty and assertive, determination to find a way, MECC is so relevant to her service’s work, delivering training is not what they want to do, highly engaged team delivering routinely, keen and invested staff, sense of obligation after spending half a day on the training, already strongly motivated to deliver from knowing MECC's impact, being tenacious in emailing teams, lost motivation, then chased about four delivery sessions, MECC ambassador/champion role motivates people to lead, people who love MECC and become champions will want to be trainers, passion for delivering keeps some people going, own passion for delivering, saw delivering the training as a way to boost low team morale, relief at being let off delivering, keen because MECC seemed set to be something big

Knowing delivery was expected
Attenders knowing beforehand that they are expected to deliver, and being the right people to attend
Whether attenders understood, when they signed up, that the session would make them trainers who must deliver, and whether those attending meant and were placed to deliver.Not realising they would have to deliver; unclear adverts or course name; coming to learn MECC, for a CV or qualification rather than to cascade; managers putting people forward without knowing; making the expectation explicit; targeting the session at those who will deliver.Commitments, deadlines or follow-up after the session (goes to Follow-up and structure); Not knowing what content to deliver (goes to Understanding the content)
Open labels it gathers (34)

people loath to sign up to train the trainer, didn't realise what they were signing up to, targeting train the trainer at engaged teams, individuals signing up trust-wide won't do anything with it, attenders not realising they have to deliver, making it explicit that attenders are expected to deliver, students attended for a qualification, not to deliver, some attenders just happy to come, not to deliver, clear communication that being a trainer means only a few courses a year, unclear from the advert what would be expected of her as a trainer afterwards, some attenders signed up to learn MECC, not to become trainers, separate offer of core MECC training so TtT goes to those who will cascade, people on her course wanted MECC for own practice, not to cascade, not everybody wants or feels confident to cascade, being clear no previous training experience is needed, attending for the CV rather than to deliver, finding the right individuals to train as trainers, attenders only told on the day they were expected to deliver four sessions a year, attenders not prepared to deliver because they did not understand they had to deliver training, attenders came expecting an awareness course, not to become trainers, expectation to deliver four sessions came as a surprise; did not know how, own expectation was to be an ambassador, not to deliver training, 'Train the Trainer' name does not tell you that you will have to deliver training, TtT delivered to staff of any level rather than managerial level, junior staff expected to train more senior staff, other attenders he knew had no clue what they were meant to do, colleagues on later TtT also did not understand expectations, delivery expectation not stated at sign-up, TtT only for people who want to deliver, renaming it 'Become a MECC Trainer' would make clear what you sign up for, know the expectations beforehand so they leave with a plan, managers put people forward not knowing it was a trainer course, did not take in the commitment to deliver until the session began, fellow attenders taken aback on hearing the expectation to deliver

Follow-up and structure
A plan, structure, follow-up and accountability after the session
Whether there was a plan, a next step, follow-up contact or accountability for delivering after the TtT session.No structure or next step; nobody making contact or checking; being left to take it forward alone; planning meetings; agreed numbers of sessions within a deadline; follow-up meetings; being asked to deliver by a lead.Peer forums and coordinators offering help (goes to Support networks); Refresher training (goes to Time lapse and refreshers); An organisation-wide MECC implementation plan (goes to Organisational priority)
Open labels it gathers (38)

team meetings to plan how to implement the training, everyone who did TtT expected to be involved in delivery, required number of sessions within 12 months means all trainers deliver, further delivery only if the MECC lead asks, commitment to deliver four core MECC sessions within a year, advice to book first core MECC within four weeks, working with targeted teams gives leverage to follow up, no authority over individual trainers, how to organise the training with other people, not knowing where to start, a gap or void after the course: ready to do what, no structure or support after the TtT, no organisation of how to carry on after the course, a clearly identified structure from course to delivering sessions, nobody contacted him after the training, follow-up of attenders after training, follow-up meeting some time after asking what you have done, course finished, goodbye: no follow-through, the right input would help prioritise and create the time, being offered a next step after the course, no communication from the end of the course, keeping in touch after the course, monitoring what trainers do with their training, more emphasis on what happens after the course, targeting what each trainer wants to be involved with, follow-up asking if any help is wanted, unsure how to put learning into practice, reiterating the expectation to deliver, nobody checks whether trainers actually deliver, coming out with a plan already discussed, back then just expected to cascade with no structure after, too left to the individual to take forward, an implementation plan of action made in the session, action-focused local support with actions for each person, something needed to make it actionable after the session, follow-up session to practise presenting with feedback, no further pressure to deliver after the TtT, trust follow-up call was not pursued

Trainer confidence
Confidence and experience as a trainer or presenter
The attender's (or others') confidence, nerves and prior experience in standing up and delivering training.Previous training, teaching or presenting experience; nerves, feeling daunted, not a natural presenter; confidence growing with practice; rehearsing.Not understanding MECC content or not knowing enough to answer questions (goes to Understanding the content); Confidence fading because time passed (goes to Time lapse and refreshers)
Open labels it gathers (58)

comfortable delivering after years implementing MECC at work, already used to standing up and delivering sessions weekly, colleagues who attended already deliver sessions in their programmes, so confident, long prior MECC experience made becoming the team's trainer feel natural, no prior experience of training delivery makes delivering daunting, past experience gave confidence to deliver even without TtT, fellow attenders at different levels of MECC and delivery experience, time booked for the trainer team to practise delivery together, practice runs with wider team as guinea pigs, line manager possibly nervous about delivering to a close-knit audience as an outsider, confident to deliver straight after the TtT, colleague has not delivered training before, trained colleagues not confident to deliver, lack of confidence to do the training, already confident delivering training, health and training background made it easy to transition to delivering, not having done training before makes delivering daunting, outgoing, can stand up and talk to people, first delivery was daunting, never delivered training before, familiarity grows the more you deliver it, rehearsing and annotating printed slides beforehand, delivering was nerve wracking the first time, being confident, not confident or comfortable delivering the training, practice over time builds confidence, elements hard to deliver confidently, behaviour therapy background gives confidence, previous teaching experience gets you through, not from a training background, insecure as a trainer, charity trainer's training background and confidence, more practice delivering would make it easier, introverted, nervous presenting, not feeling confident training, adult education qualification gives confidence to deliver, comfortable presenting from current work, lack of training experience makes delivering feel scary for others, previous experience delivering brief advice training, trained trainers don't feel comfortable delivering, trainers with no training experience lack confidence and are intimidated by presenting, face-to-face delivery now feels intimidating, new trainer nervous about setting up her first session, previous experience of delivering training and education groups, stress about delivering core MECC led me to avoid it, attenders observed felt very unconfident to deliver, lack of confidence, thinking they must deliver it like the principal trainer, not a natural presenter and teacher, worried whether her presentation skills would be OK, less confident to train very experienced team members, still feels nervous before delivering, not being trainers puts people off, delivering only once or twice a year keeps non-trainers nervous, wary and nervous about starting to deliver herself, gets easier once you've done it a few times, attenders who weren't trainers face the hurdle of actually doing it, big step for those who hadn't trained before, lack of confidence in those who've never trained before, practice run in her own centre before delivering to others

Understanding the content
Understanding of MECC content and of what to deliver
Whether the attender understood the MECC content and what they were meant to deliver well enough to teach it and answer questions.Not knowing what to deliver or train in; slides beyond them; lacking a health or public health background; worry about questions they cannot answer; feeling they know enough.General nerves about presenting (goes to Trainer confidence); The content being too long or not fitting the audience (goes to Fit of the core training)
Open labels it gathers (39)

worry about curve ball questions trainers cannot answer, familiar topic from existing person-centred questionnaire work, worried about what they’re going to be asked in the training sessions, people feel they can’t deliver because they’re not from a health background, overly complicated content leaves attenders without a health background not confident to train, not coming from a health or public health background makes delivering daunting, more on wider determinants needed for those without a health background, doubting she knows enough compared with health promotion attenders, questioning whether she knows enough to deliver, no public health background makes wider determinants hard to deliver, unfamiliar with trust signposting options, behaviour change model hard to present if new to it, taking ownership to familiarise yourself with the content, unclear what to train in, no idea what to deliver even with a co-trainer, subject too broad to know what to target, unsure on the 3A slides, felt like winging it, many models overwhelming without health background, familiar with the slides, could not remember how to use the expectation-effect slide, so left it out, did not understand what the TtT session wanted me to deliver, did not know what I was trying to deliver after TtT, core MECC slides feel way beyond my pay grade, junior attenders did not understand the content or were not interested, attenders panicking about training peers when they do not understand MECC, did not know how to deliver it after the session, left the session unclear what to deliver, only told 'you'll get the slides', now understands what to deliver, no structure: would not know where a session was going, froze at delivering core MECC: did not understand the slides, not knowing how to deliver it within their team, attenders who weren't trainers were nervous about answering questions, had to keep looking back to brush up her knowledge, felt she lacked the principal trainer's knowledge, background in public health and health promotion, can always get back to people if you don't know the answer, idea that trainers must know everything, worried they haven't the knowledge to answer questions, nervous about limited mental health knowledge for MECC mental health

The TtT session
How the TtT session itself prepared attenders to deliver
What the Train the Trainer session did or did not give attenders for delivering: practice, training skills, tips, clarity, enough time, its format and timing.No chance to practise delivering; tips on presenting; too short or a whistle-stop tour; online format with less interaction; TtT straight after core training; covering or not covering practicalities.Not being told beforehand that they would have to deliver (goes to Knowing delivery was expected); The core training package they were to deliver (goes to Fit of the core training)
Open labels it gathers (41)

no practice of delivering the training in the TtT session, TtT gave advice on improving delivery style, TtT trainer section helps those with little training experience, TtT session needed so trainers deliver to a good enough standard, TtT immediately after core training too much for colleagues new to MECC, time to reflect between core training and TtT would help, TtT focusing more on presentation skills and mock presentations, TtT gave ideas for interactive activities, TtT taught in an NHS ‘see one, do one, off you go’ style that may not suit non-NHS attenders, TtT reinforced knowledge and gave the backup of the Gateway, TtT consolidated her knowledge so she was sure enough to teach it, TtT spurred her on to deliver, TtT gives only a whistle stop tour of topics, TtT time spent on how to present difficult slides would help, more information on how to actually deliver the content, TtT gave confidence for teaching sessions, earlier online session did not equip her to deliver, online session during COVID had less interaction, short online session left manager not ready to deliver, doing core MECC shortly before TtT, attenders who went straight to TtT lacked prior knowledge, in-person TtT with principal trainer reduced nervousness, only saw finance module as a recording, could not ask questions, fellow attenders wanted more on the conversation side, more on training skills in the TtT session would help, trainer's tips on presenting (moving around the room), not invited to the finance module webinar, TtT section on how to train helps people who aren't natural trainers, TtT covering practicalities of delivering (promotion, bookings, registers, IT), little TtT content on organising sessions via the app, covering the app and booking system in the TtT would help, TtT too heavy on public health statistics, unclear what to deliver, do TtT only after awareness training and being embedded in MECC, TtT did little practice on the message to get over, TtT should be the last stage of MECC training, not the first, four hours not enough to make someone ready to train, came away from TtT bewildered, TtT gave practical tips for delivering, principal trainer told them what to do if things happen, TtT was clear and encouraging that they could do it, TtT stressing they can deliver as a pair rather than alone

Fit of the core training
Fit, length and adaptability of the core MECC training package
Whether the core MECC training they were to deliver fitted their audience and setting, its length and weight, and the work or freedom to adapt it.Too long, wordy, heavy or generic; not relevant to a sector or audience; adapting, shortening or localising it; the work adaptation takes; freedom or not to tweak it.Not understanding the content (goes to Understanding the content); Availability of slides and materials (goes to Ready-made resources)
Open labels it gathers (53)

adapting the slides to suit participants and trainers, example topic (diet) not relevant to her audience, linking topics to what trainees accept as their responsibility, not able to put her personal touch on the training, tweaking slides makes trainers more confident, need for identical training across teams limits tweaking, core MECC content is really wordy, core MECC is really long, even boring to deliver, adding her own practice examples to the core training, no group activities in the core MECC, adding her own group activity to the training, simplifying content (one model of change) would help, adapting and re-explaining slides in simpler terms, removing content not relevant to her team, some core content not relevant to a mental health nursing audience, using a version already adapted to the service, not as much time for the session, so slides had to be hidden, too much content built into the trust's version, too many behaviour change models, content too heavy for a diverse audience, simplifying content by keeping one behaviour change model, trying to cram a lot into the session, staff find the content overwhelming, cancer-specific case studies help tailor the training to her setting, evidence of MECC efficacy in the core training would give credibility with clinical audiences, shortened session leaves no time for interactive activities, MECC felt too general and woolly to deliver as training, adding a trust-specific slide to make training relevant, training videos not specific to mental health staff, harder to engage them, able to drop content she was not comfortable delivering, sessions to deliver are half a day long, keeping own delivery basic, within my knowledge, core slides top heavy with stats, a lot of work needed to adapt it after TtT, adapting it to make it locally specific and comfortable to deliver, healthcare focus doesn't translate to VCSE attenders, a lot of adaptation work left after the session, sector-specific MECC sessions, slide deck not their own, have to make it their own, standard core MECC doesn't fit fire and rescue's programme, standard MECC risks seeming irrelevant to fire and rescue staff, help to adapt slides and build a signposting toolkit, full core session may be too much to deliver to a team, short taster sessions in team meetings, equip people to run facilitated team conversations, reshaping training around a relevant topic with signposting and facts, core MECC training too generic, lack of capacity and motivation to use add-on modules to adapt sessions, understanding what MECC looks like in your organisation, reframing the training as highlighting resources to expert colleagues, adapting the training to acknowledge colleagues' expertise, ice cream van slide hard to explain when delivering, slides revised to ones much easier to explain, it's only half a day to deliver

Ready-made resources
Ready-made slides, materials, guides and signposting resources
Whether the materials needed to deliver were ready, findable and suitable: slides, cards, videos, guides, the MECC Gateway, local signposting information.Everything ready-made; resources scattered or hard to find; suggestions for a how-to guide or one folder; printed packs; local signposting resources.Difficulty using the online platforms or booking app (goes to Platforms and admin)
Open labels it gathers (61)

slides, resources and handouts all ready-made, knowing the work has been done for them motivates people to deliver, pre-populated PowerPoints, role play scenarios in the resources, prompt cards to give participants, online resources sufficient to deliver by editing them herself, modular slides you could cut and paste in, MECC app as a resource for trainees, up-to-date online resources and refresh emails, guides on hands-on activities would help, non-IT based resources as a contingency, printers available to print materials, MECC slides put on a digital platform so people can do it in their own time, MECC Gateway means trainers don’t need to know all the answers, new PowerPoint templates on Future NHS to offer alongside the training, offering extra resources alongside MECC increases uptake of the training, resources not made clear in the training, had to find them herself, the MECC Gateway gives trainers all the information, learning about the Gateway in TtT enabled her to signpost to it in her training, Connect 5 resource relevant to her service, local directory found through other training to signpost to, trust-specific signposting document given to all trainers, not aware of MECC Gateway or NHS Futures resources, has not accessed the slides and resources, useful range of videos in resources, resources such as sign in sheets, Z cards only online, have to print them, struggling to find the resources needed to prepare her first session, step-by-step how-to guide for getting the first session going would help, guidance on what local information to add to the slide deck would help, resources all over the place, unsure which to include in her sessions, written how-to guide rather than only video would help, clear step-by-step guide would overcome lack of training confidence, one folder with everything needed to deliver a first session would help, trainers without time to search need resources in one place, link to course registration in a first-course folder would help, editable PDF poster to advertise courses would help, MECC Gateway a credible resource to use in her training, step-by-step guide and core resources in one place, regional MECC website topic information to fall back on, standardised regional training package as a template made sessions easy to organise, MECC Gateway website to signpost trainees to, physical training manual as a safety net, being spoon fed materials would help those for whom it's not their role, a physical MECC pack would have helped, prompt cards to feel comfortable at first training session, tiered resources with a dedicated trainer section, NHS Futures platform with resources, add-on slides equip people to cascade, local signposting not yet good enough, guidance to organisations on signposting toolbox not enough, sharing local signposting with new trainers, developing a signposting tool and building around it, effective signposting not cracked, ready-made local signposting resource would move organisations forward, FutureNHS platform holds all the information, good resources and weekly forum email updates, training covered everything and can be adapted with slides, the basic PowerPoint is all she usually needs, cost of printing the prompt cards, useful resources such as the bus journey graphic

Platforms and admin
Online platforms, registration and the administration of sessions
The online platforms (Future NHS, booking app, websites), IT skills, certificates, registers and evaluation paperwork, and help with this administration.Clunky or changing platforms; too many emails; confusing registration app; certificate problems; admin burden; admin support or a colleague handling bookings.The content of the resources themselves (goes to Ready-made resources); IT or wi-fi at the venue where sessions are given (goes to Getting an audience)
Open labels it gathers (32)

staff to be trained have no work emails for evaluation surveys, workload of managing paper evaluation surveys, had booking infrastructure in place, Futures platform hard to navigate, constant slide and video updates on Futures overwhelming, heavy admin burden of running the programme, regional booking app glitchy for trainers to set up their training, admin support in the team, navigating the regional app another barrier for trainers, simple in-house arrangement with paper registers, no help or pushing to get on the app, not comfortable enough going online, participants unable to register on ICS platform, certificate problems for the finance module, Futures platform clunky, bombarded with Futures emails so important messages missed, confusing terminology (the 'app' for registering courses), had to dig around to find the app for registering courses, has time for admin: setting up the app, evaluating sessions, set up sessions and handled all admin for trainers, people struggle with IT skills, logging on to the training app and Future NHS is a barrier, she sends adapted slides directly so trainers avoid the platform, Future NHS platform daunting, things in different places, portal very busy and constantly changing, got lost in the MECC portal, portal too confusing, stopped using it, overwhelmed by constantly evolving information, simple delivery logistics, little to carry or paperwork, struggled with the MECC website at first, colleague handles the booking, saving her time, sometimes could not get certificates from the website

Getting an audience
Getting trainees together: release, scheduling, demand, venues and mode
Whether the attender could get a group of trainees to a session: staff released and available, scheduling, demand and promotion, venues, online or face-to-face delivery, and existing slots to deliver in.Staff not released or too busy to attend; shifts and dispersed sites; low turnout; no group to teach; existing CPD, induction or training slots; teams requesting training; promotion; venues, IT at venues; online versus face-to-face.Trainees' attitude once in the room (goes to Trainee receptiveness); The trainer's own lack of time (goes to Time and workload)
Open labels it gathers (79)

getting staff together at the same time, staff to be trained work shifts or are part time or casual, staff spread across five different centres, team leads in each centre gave the best times, using site closures when staff are free to run sessions, finding the space and time to get everybody together, organising cascade to large numbers of people is hard, proposed groups of up to 50 too large to deliver to, having to sell it to team leads and managers, spare time in existing drill-night training slots, could not combine MECC with other training trips, combining MECC with other training already booked, terrible wi-fi and IT in old buildings, logistics of seeing every team in person and booking it all, online training doesn't work for the audience, needs in person, framing MECC as the hub with other training as spokes to sell the core MECC, actively reaching out to other services to offer training, selling the training as building staff resilience, advertising the training in the newsletter would help, give-and-take deals with services, in-house trainers can offer training at times that suit their service, no visual feedback when delivering online, stony silence from online audience, delivering online lets you keep notes in front of you, existing weekly CPD hour to deliver in, took over a session the MECC lead had already planned, rolling CPD programme gives a slot to deliver again, face to face delivery more time consuming for people, without the CPD slot it would mean finding a time, place and spot in diaries, staff too busy to attend training, slot already pencilled in, bite size training slot available to request, time pressured organisation, staff can’t get to training, core MECC sessions labour intensive with very low numbers attending, weaving MECC into pre-existing training programmes, captive audience on existing programmes, low attendance at core MECC sessions across the region, comms and promotion generate requests for training, banging the drum, hard to get people to take notice, ready-made audience, no need to hunt for a group, delivery built into existing education days, volunteers’ time to attend training, cost of venues, free venue available at the community centre, no group to teach, hard to book training venues because of clinical and mandatory training, able to promote the training in management and team meetings, online attendees don't put cameras on or engage, delivering online alone means juggling screens and watching for questions, face-to-face sessions terribly attended, staff reluctant to travel to face-to-face sessions, staff cannot be released for a three-hour session, presenting online to a screen feels less intimidating, presentations at trust-wide managers meeting get the message out, promoting MECC at physical health link worker and champion meetings, staff teams requesting training for their teams, earlier contacts to arrange training fell flat with no response, online delivery reaches large groups without a venue, building MECC training into induction and preceptee training days, shortening the session made it easier to release staff, trainer has saturated his local site, no one else interested, deliver MECC training at induction to new starters, being invited along to a team meeting, ward staff have no time even for mandatory training, colleagues built MECC into their existing topic training, delivering online avoids travel to venues, less interaction when delivering virtually, colleague built MECC into her healthy weight training, apprehensive whether the technology and PowerPoint would work, team dotted around a wide area made cascading a challenge, never asked her team whether they wanted the training, team spread over a huge geographical area, delivering on Teams to reach a dispersed team, Monday morning session timing, people don't want to teach online, colleague recruits people onto the courses, IT issues at venues, not all venues have a projector, colleague organises and advertises the sessions

Trainee receptiveness
How receptive the people being trained were
The attitude of the staff or volunteers being trained, and the trainer's relationship with them.'We already do that'; resistance; trainees forced to attend or not interested; receptive or keen trainees; good relationships with the audience; critical audiences.Trainees not being able to attend (goes to Getting an audience)
Open labels it gathers (28)

resistance expected from staff who are to be trained, good relationships with the teams she would train, trainees feel health topics are not their thing, trainer's existing relationship makes trainees receptive, tight-knit teams that may decide they're not interested, audience already having similar conversations under existing values, trainees' enthusiasm from the new referral model, council staff attitude ‘we already do that’, so why need the training, delivering to people she knows, critical NHS staff in the audience, separating NHS and other audiences would help delivery, worry about trainees' reactions to the content, worry trainees will see MECC as a waste of time as they already do it, trainees more receptive than expected, MECC better received by people in the last year, staff being trained do not understand what MECC training is training them in, delivering to new care certificate learners who are receptive, established clinical departments resistant to being trained in MECC, calling it 'training' raises established staff's expectations, too much resistance in old position, so hid away from delivering, resistance makes most attenders hide away from delivering, services don't see that what they already do is MECC, participants knew each other and had a regular meeting place, felt she would be teaching colleagues what they already do every day, some groups she trains will not interact, trainees forced there by their manager or not interested, keen trainees, many of them volunteer health champions, negative feedback from a flat session put her off a little

Co-delivery and buddying
Co-delivering, buddying, shadowing and observing
Delivering with another trainer, having a buddy, or watching an experienced trainer before delivering, or the lack of this.Co-delivery with a colleague or fellow attender; delivering alone; shadowing or observing sessions; an experienced trainer going through materials with a new one.Help from the regional coordinator or a forum (goes to Support networks)
Open labels it gathers (31)

experienced attender on board to support colleagues with delivery, two trainers delivering each session, most experienced attender leads and brings colleagues up to standard, swapping trainers so whoever knew the team best delivered, colleague comes along to observe the sessions she delivers first, colleague not a ‘see one, do one’ learner so needs to observe before delivering, future trainers see her deliver it first before going on train the trainer, existing trust trainer welcomes her as support, public health team offers refreshers and co-facilitation, fellow attender offered to deliver together, co-delivering with two trainers, co-delivering with a finance colleague, having a co-host, linking non-delivering attenders up to co-facilitate, buddy who is delivering to go to for advice, a buddy would have helped her find resources, a buddy to co-deliver would instil confidence, seeing the course delivered before delivering it herself, no co-deliverer for MECC, delivers alone, co-facilitating and buddying with other trainers, a buddy to co-deliver would have helped her, shadowing every session the principal trainer delivered, experienced trainer going through the materials with a new trainer, joint delivery with an experienced trainer for a first session, offered shadowing and co-facilitation to trained staff, seeing it delivered at care certificate level, team approach to delivery with colleagues, own team are trainers already, delivering as a pair is easier, colleague sometimes co-delivers with her, co-delivering colleague only occasionally available due to other roles

Support networks
Support from coordinators, principal trainers, forums, local leads and peers
Whether attenders had and used support after the session: the regional coordinator and principal trainer, the trainers' forum, local MECC leads and peer networks.Coordinator on hand; local MECC leads' help; forums too long, irrelevant or unattended; no time to attend support; isolation; not knowing who to ask; peer support suggested.Co-delivering with another trainer (goes to Co-delivery and buddying); Refresher training (goes to Time lapse and refreshers)
Open labels it gathers (81)

regional coordinator agreed to tweaks to the training, regional coordinator quickly on hand with questions, little peer support: regional forum small, peer support networks and networking worthwhile, embarrassing to be in trainers' meetings having not delivered, peer support to check how others deliver particular slides, regional MECC emails and conference long and NHS-led, not relevant to a council setting, ongoing support offered to the trainers she creates, handholding needed to get delivery up and running, can email the regional coordinator and principal trainer and use the forum, regional trainers’ forum too long, forum is showcasey and not applicable to her setting, a more collaborative forum working on resources together would help, peer support would help, people are afraid to ask for help, help from the trust MECC lead, no time to attend trainers’ support groups, reassuring feedback from a colleague after delivering, tips from the trust MECC link worker, without the link worker’s support it would have been different, support from the MECC link worker, no time for peer support groups, low turnout at trainers' peer support group, monthly informal peer support session for trainers, trainers don't attend support sessions because not mandatory, monthly cross-organisation update training for trainers, low uptake of update sessions by trainers, trainers need additional support to deliver, little interaction with fellow attenders, could not get into the online meeting, support to set up the first session, isolation from the rest of the group, attenders who knew each other likely keep in contact, not encouraged to use the available avenues, peer support networks beneficial and cost effective, regional lead had left, city-wide MECC group with attenders starting to deliver, regional coordinator responds quickly, trainers' forum clashes with other things, support of the regional team, regional group helps authorities catch up, open peer session on anything trainers are struggling with, chance to clarify questions before starting to train, local council MECC trainers' brunch to support roll-out, illness meant she could not join the trainers' forum, not confident to ask the coordinator for help, so they just don't, local peer network to learn from others delivering, network meeting on her doorstep (no time to travel far), high workload means she skips the regional trainers' forum, local network shares knowledge of the same population, few trained staff engaged with the trust trainers' forum and refresher sessions, a community of trainers who come together, respected ex-manager also delivering MECC, a role model and ally, did not understand the support offered after TtT, unsure whether could join the forums, a trust-level MECC group would help, clinical staff have no time for portal or Teams forum, verbal support from own team, did not know who to ask for help, a local go-to person or champion, single regional contact may not respond or feel approachable, internal resource support mechanism, accessible principal trainer and coordinator for support, regional trainer forum and steering group, support needed after the session, unclear who will support the attender afterwards, working with individual organisations to support cascade, peer network of other MECC leads, hard for an outsider to tell organisations how to deliver MECC, more input with organisations to get it in motion, aware there was a lot of support available after the TtT, coordinator and principal trainer would help if she delivered, trainers' support sessions felt supportive, local in-person support groups for an organisation's trained staff, would ask principal trainer or coordinator for guidance on adapting it, peer support group to share how others overcame obstacles, no time in work life to attend everything online, no time to attend trainers' meetings, regional coordinator available when struggling, works part time, hard to find time for network meetings, network meetings would help by sharing others' difficulties

Time lapse and refreshers
Training fading over time, and refreshers
Whether time passing after the session left attenders out of practice or forgetful, and whether refresher training helped.Forgetting the training; confidence fading; no longer fresh; out of practice; refresher TtT or update sessions.COVID or illness causing the delay (goes to Disruption)
Open labels it gathers (24)

training no longer fresh in her mind after the delay, refresher before delivering to infrequent new cohorts, refresher training (possibly online) would help, refresher with local area data would help, refresher training every year or two would help, time lapse since training, need a refresher before delivering, refresher TtT sessions would help, would need to re-read the slides before delivering, out of practice when asked to deliver at short notice, refresher training so delivering trainers know they are on track, refresher training for attenders who have not delivered yet, short online refresher sessions would instil confidence, nervous about delivering after a long gap from training, trained staff forgot it, no chance to practise or deliver, redoing the TtT refreshed her on changed resources, trainers trained before COVID have forgotten the training, yearly refresher as a support structure, refresher brings cascading back on the agenda, confidence faded as time went on without using it, trouble retaining the information from the TtT, refresher by redoing the TtT session, hard to go back to it and retain it after events following the TtT, did a refresher TtT when it restarted, refresher TtT after six months

Disruption
COVID, illness, personal events and staff turnover
Events outside the programme that interrupted delivery: COVID, illness, personal crises, job moves and staff turnover.COVID halting delivery; illness or personal events after the session; trained trainers moving jobs; staff rotating.Ordinary workload and competing work (goes to Time and workload)
Open labels it gathers (15)

COVID made earlier attenders disengage, trainer's operation paused delivery, COVID stopped earlier MECC trainers, MECC put on back burner during COVID, off sick soon after the TtT session delayed delivery, COVID came along after her first trainer training and she forgot it, COVID lockdown stopped trust's 70-80 trained trainers delivering, COVID pressures on wards, capacity and caseloads, trained trainers have moved jobs, other organisations also struggling to re-engage trained trainers, staff turnover loses trained people, staff rotating through services, personal circumstances the day after the TtT meant she had to shelve it, motivation vanished within 24 hours because of life events, COVID stopped delivery after her first TtT

Left in no item: colleagues trained in train the trainer don’t do anything with it (Describes that attenders did not deliver (an outcome) rather than anything that stopped or helped them); only about 10% of trained staff deliver routinely (Describes that attenders did not deliver (an outcome) rather than anything that stopped or helped them); trained people not delivering on the ground (Describes that attenders did not deliver (an outcome) rather than anything that stopped or helped them); her own sessions being available means others don't bother delivering (A one-off account that the lead's own central sessions made others' delivery unnecessary; fits no item and is too singular for one of its own); getting organisations to cascade is proving difficult (Describes that attenders did not deliver (an outcome) rather than anything that stopped or helped them); people she trains fall short of cascading within their team (Describes that attenders did not deliver (an outcome) rather than anything that stopped or helped them); attenders not doing anything with it once they leave the room (Describes that attenders did not deliver (an outcome) rather than anything that stopped or helped them).

What grouping the labels merged, split or left alone

Items name a factor without its direction; the step f column 'kind' keeps barriers and facilitators apart, so each item is counted separately on each side. Drawn once from all 810 open labels after every document was coded. Line manager kept apart from organisation-wide priority; confidence as a trainer kept apart from understanding the content; the TtT session kept apart from the core package attenders deliver; platforms kept apart from resources. AP10's wait for bespoke slides from a partner organisation is placed under Organisational priority, as a process that held delivery up, not as a lack of resources. Labels that only state that attenders did not deliver are left unplaced.

Counting: Attenders by cascaded

Attenders by cascaded

Attenders interviewed, by whether the document list records them as having cascaded the training.

The table 2 cells
CascadedAttenders
Yes of 13
No of 13

Counting: Status by cascaded and delivered in transcript

Attenders by cascaded and delivered in transcript

Attenders by whether the document list records them as having cascaded and whether they say in the interview that they have delivered MECC training, out of all 13 attenders.

The table 6 cells
CascadedDelivered in transcriptAttenders
Yes of 7
No of 6
No of 6
NoUnclear of 6
Yes of 7
YesUnclear of 7

Counting: Label by item and cascaded (barrier, own, actual)

Attenders by item and cascaded

Attenders describing each kind of barrier that actually stood in the way of their own delivery of MECC training, by whether the document list records them as having cascaded, out of the 7 recorded as cascaded and the 6 recorded as not.

The table 42 cells
ItemCascadedAttenders
Fit of the core trainingYes of 7
Time and workloadNo of 6
Getting an audienceNo of 6
Getting an audienceYes of 7
Support networksNo of 6
Platforms and adminNo of 6
Ready-made resourcesYes of 7
Support networksYes of 7
Trainee receptivenessYes of 7
Trainer confidenceYes of 7
Understanding the contentYes of 7
DisruptionYes of 7
Knowing delivery was expectedNo of 6
Line managerNo of 6
Organisational priorityYes of 7
Platforms and adminYes of 7
Trainee receptivenessNo of 6
DisruptionNo of 6
Fit of the core trainingNo of 6
Follow-up and structureNo of 6
Follow-up and structureYes of 7
Job roleNo of 6
Organisational priorityNo of 6
Personal motivationNo of 6
Ready-made resourcesNo of 6
Time and workloadYes of 7
Time lapse and refreshersNo of 6
Time lapse and refreshersYes of 7
Trainer confidenceNo of 6
Understanding the contentNo of 6
Co-delivery and buddyingYes of 7
Job roleYes of 7
Line managerYes of 7
Pay and incentivesNo of 6
The TtT sessionNo of 6
The TtT sessionYes of 7
Co-delivery and buddyingNo of 6
Knowing delivery was expectedYes of 7
OTHERNo of 6
OTHERYes of 7
Pay and incentivesYes of 7
Personal motivationYes of 7

Counting: Label by item and cascaded (facilitator, own, actual)

Attenders by item and cascaded

Attenders describing each kind of facilitator that was actually present for their own delivery of MECC training, by whether the document list records them as having cascaded, out of the 7 recorded as cascaded and the 6 recorded as not.

The table 42 cells
ItemCascadedAttenders
Organisational priorityYes of 7
Fit of the core trainingYes of 7
Getting an audienceYes of 7
Support networksYes of 7
Co-delivery and buddyingYes of 7
Job roleYes of 7
Ready-made resourcesYes of 7
Trainer confidenceNo of 6
Co-delivery and buddyingNo of 6
Personal motivationNo of 6
Personal motivationYes of 7
Ready-made resourcesNo of 6
Support networksNo of 6
The TtT sessionNo of 6
The TtT sessionYes of 7
Trainer confidenceYes of 7
Getting an audienceNo of 6
Job roleNo of 6
Line managerNo of 6
Line managerYes of 7
Platforms and adminYes of 7
Time and workloadYes of 7
Trainee receptivenessYes of 7
Fit of the core trainingNo of 6
Organisational priorityNo of 6
Pay and incentivesYes of 7
Time lapse and refreshersYes of 7
Trainee receptivenessNo of 6
Understanding the contentNo of 6
Understanding the contentYes of 7
Follow-up and structureNo of 6
Platforms and adminNo of 6
DisruptionNo of 6
DisruptionYes of 7
Follow-up and structureYes of 7
Knowing delivery was expectedNo of 6
Knowing delivery was expectedYes of 7
OTHERNo of 6
OTHERYes of 7
Pay and incentivesNo of 6
Time and workloadNo of 6
Time lapse and refreshersNo of 6

Counting: Label by item and kind (others)

Attenders by item and kind

Attenders reporting each kind of barrier or facilitator for specific other attenders they trained, managed, worked with or met, out of all 13 attenders interviewed.

The table 43 cells
ItemKindAttenders
Trainer confidence of 13
Knowing delivery was expected of 13
Co-delivery and buddying of 13
Time and workload of 13
Support networks of 13
Support networks of 13
Understanding the content of 13
None of 13
Follow-up and structure of 13
Job role of 13
Ready-made resources of 13
Co-delivery and buddying of 13
Disruption of 13
Fit of the core training of 13
Getting an audience of 13
Getting an audience of 13
Job role of 13
Line manager of 13
Pay and incentives of 13
Platforms and admin of 13
The TtT session of 13
Time lapse and refreshers of 13
Trainer confidence of 13
Follow-up and structure of 13
Knowing delivery was expected of 13
Line manager of 13
Organisational priority of 13
Personal motivation of 13
Personal motivation of 13
Platforms and admin of 13
Ready-made resources of 13
The TtT session of 13
Time lapse and refreshers of 13
Disruption of 13
Fit of the core training of 13
OTHER of 13
OTHER of 13
Organisational priority of 13
Pay and incentives of 13
Time and workload of 13
Trainee receptiveness of 13
Trainee receptiveness of 13
Understanding the content of 13

Counting: Label by item and kind (general)

Attenders by item and kind

Attenders giving each kind of barrier or facilitator as a general view of what stops or helps attenders cascade, out of all 13 attenders interviewed.

The table 43 cells
ItemKindAttenders
Support networks of 13
Time and workload of 13
Trainer confidence of 13
Getting an audience of 13
Time lapse and refreshers of 13
Ready-made resources of 13
Understanding the content of 13
Follow-up and structure of 13
Knowing delivery was expected of 13
Organisational priority of 13
Support networks of 13
The TtT session of 13
The TtT session of 13
Co-delivery and buddying of 13
Job role of 13
Knowing delivery was expected of 13
Line manager of 13
Fit of the core training of 13
Fit of the core training of 13
Pay and incentives of 13
Platforms and admin of 13
Understanding the content of 13
Follow-up and structure of 13
Getting an audience of 13
Line manager of 13
Organisational priority of 13
Personal motivation of 13
Time and workload of 13
Trainee receptiveness of 13
Disruption of 13
Job role of 13
Pay and incentives of 13
Ready-made resources of 13
Trainee receptiveness of 13
Trainer confidence of 13
None of 13
Co-delivery and buddying of 13
Disruption of 13
OTHER of 13
OTHER of 13
Personal motivation of 13
Platforms and admin of 13
Time lapse and refreshers of 13

Counting: Label by item and cascaded (facilitator, own, prospective)

Attenders by item and cascaded

Attenders saying what would help, or would have helped, their own delivery of MECC training, by kind and by whether the document list records them as having cascaded, out of the 7 recorded as cascaded and the 6 recorded as not.

The table 42 cells
ItemCascadedAttenders
Support networksNo of 6
Fit of the core trainingNo of 6
Getting an audienceNo of 6
Ready-made resourcesNo of 6
Time lapse and refreshersNo of 6
Trainer confidenceYes of 7
Co-delivery and buddyingYes of 7
Getting an audienceYes of 7
Support networksYes of 7
Co-delivery and buddyingNo of 6
Follow-up and structureNo of 6
Line managerNo of 6
Ready-made resourcesYes of 7
The TtT sessionNo of 6
The TtT sessionYes of 7
Trainee receptivenessYes of 7
Trainer confidenceNo of 6
DisruptionNo of 6
DisruptionYes of 7
Fit of the core trainingYes of 7
Follow-up and structureYes of 7
Job roleNo of 6
Job roleYes of 7
Knowing delivery was expectedNo of 6
Knowing delivery was expectedYes of 7
Line managerYes of 7
OTHERNo of 6
OTHERYes of 7
Organisational priorityNo of 6
Organisational priorityYes of 7
Pay and incentivesNo of 6
Pay and incentivesYes of 7
Personal motivationNo of 6
Personal motivationYes of 7
Platforms and adminNo of 6
Platforms and adminYes of 7
Time and workloadNo of 6
Time and workloadYes of 7
Time lapse and refreshersYes of 7
Trainee receptivenessNo of 6
Understanding the contentNo of 6
Understanding the contentYes of 7

Counting: Attenders by cascaded and gender

Attenders by cascaded and gender

Attenders by whether the document list records them as having cascaded and by gender as the document list gives it.

The table 4 cells
CascadedGenderAttenders
YesFemale of 13
NoFemale of 13
NoMale of 13
YesMale of 13

Key claims

  • Every attender recorded as cascading described an organisation that wanted MECC delivered, often with a ready slot or contract to deliver into, and most said delivering training was part of their job; but some who did not cascade also had backing or a role that included delivery.
    Each attender recorded as cascading names organisational backing, and most name their role or a contract, as what made delivery happen; the rows against show backing or a delivering role present for attenders who still had not delivered, and AP4 saying a job-plan expectation would not help AP4. Rests on: . Against: . Found by: Step f rows with kind facilitator, whose own, actual actual, item Job role, Organisational priority, Pay and incentives or Getting an audience, read across the two groups of the document list's cascaded column.
  • What stopped attenders who did not cascade was mainly competing work without protected time, and for some line managers who set no expectation, gave no time or did not sign off.
    The passages give workload, short staffing, competing duties, and a manager's lack of expectation, time or sign-off as what held delivery back; against them, some non-cascaders had supportive managers and some cascaders also met capacity limits. Rests on: . Against: . Found by: Step f rows with kind barrier, whose own, actual actual, item Time and workload or Line manager, for attenders the document list records as not cascaded.
  • Attenders who did not cascade describe being left without structure, a next step or follow-up after the session.
    AP2 and AP8 describe no contact, structure or pressure after the session; AP8 also knew support was available, and AP7 delivered despite having no structure afterwards. Rests on: . Against: . Found by: Step f rows with kind barrier, whose own, item Follow-up and structure.
  • Confidence as a trainer did not separate those who cascaded from those who did not: most non-cascaders felt able to deliver and several cascaders were nervous.
    Non-cascaders report confidence and experience while cascaders report nerves; AP8 and AP6 are the exceptions where lack of confidence or stress held delivery back. Rests on: . Against: . Found by: Step f rows with whose own, actual actual, item Trainer confidence, compared across the two groups.
  • Those who cascaded met the core training's length and weight once delivering, and adapted, shortened or rebuilt it to fit their audience and the time staff could be released.
    The passages describe the core course as long, heavy or ill-fitting and the changes made to deliver it; AP9 describes it as manageable as it stands. Rests on: . Against: . Found by: Step f rows with whose own, actual actual, item Fit of the core training, for attenders recorded as cascaded.
  • Some attenders did not realise, when they signed up, that the session committed them to deliver training, or came for other reasons.
    Interviewees report themselves or fellow attenders not understanding the expectation to deliver, or attending for other reasons; AP13 shows a commitment stated at sign-up did not on its own produce delivery. AP3 says the expectation was made explicit in AP3's council. Rests on: . Against: . Found by: Step f rows with kind barrier, item Knowing delivery was expected, whose own or others.
  • Whole groups of trained attenders stopped delivering when COVID halted delivery, and the training faded and people moved on before it restarted.
    AP5 and AP3 describe trained groups halted by COVID who forgot the training, lost capacity or moved jobs; AP9 restarted after a refresher session. Rests on: . Against: . Found by: Step f rows with item Disruption or Time lapse and refreshers, whose others, and the AP13 row on the share of trained staff delivering.
  • AP6, recorded as not cascaded, describes delivering an adapted MECC session in care certificate training after moving to a public health role, while avoiding the core course in that role and having had no time to deliver in the former clinical role.
    AP6's own account places delivery after the move into a role where delivering is expected, and none before it. Rests on: . Against: . Found by: The status step row for AP6 and AP6's step f rows on job role and confidence.
  • Interviewees describe other attenders delivering where their job already included education or training, and not delivering where it did not, where they lacked support back at work, or where the job was seen as someone else's.
    Coordinators and fellow attenders attribute others' delivery to education roles and non-delivery to roles without training, unsupportive managers and handing delivery back to the lead; capacity is given alongside role as a reason. Rests on: . Against: . Found by: Step f rows with whose others or general and item Job role, Line manager or Time and workload, read for what interviewees say separates others who deliver from those who do not.

Writing: Answer

The instruction the answer was written to

What the evaluator was asked to agree

The documents and the settled question with its design (2026-10-22T10:34:17+01:00). Put to the evaluator in the chat; their answer is as the AI that asked recorded it. They answered: Are these the documents: the 13 attender interviews (7 recorded cascaded, 6 not) plus two background files used for context only? Yes, use them (recommended) - default taken: the evaluator was not available in this session; Accept the settled question and its design (cases = attender interviews; barriers and facilitators kept apart; own / other attenders / general accounts kept apart; index cascaded column as the comparison, checked against each transcript; several factors per person, each counted once per person per side; categories drawn from the documents by open coding and a soft recode; a check as second reading; no rubric; no out-of-frame section)? Accept (recommended) - default taken: the evaluator was not available in this session; Second reading before the draft is shown A check by a fresh reader (recommended) - default taken; Route to the codebook Soft recode (recommended) - default taken; Add a section for material outside the question's frame? No - default taken.

  • The documents, as shown under What was read.
  • The question, as shown at the head of this report.

Each was set out to them only by the AI that asked, so that it was shown is the AI's word.

The codebook drawn from the open labels, and the actual/prospective column (2026-10-22T11:03:18+01:00). Put to the evaluator in the chat; their answer is as the AI that asked recorded it. They answered: Accept the codebook of 20 items drawn from the 810 open labels (shown in chat as a table with an example passage for each), with each item counted separately as a barrier or a facilitator? Accept (recommended) - default taken: the evaluator was not available in this session; Add an 'actual or prospective' column so that help and barriers that actually occurred are counted apart from what interviewees say would help? Yes (recommended) - default taken.

Each was set out to them only by the AI that asked, so that it was shown is the AI's word.

The checks that were run

  • 822 of 822 coded passages found word for word in their document.
  • 96 of 96 quotations in the answer found word for word in the documents (a quotation of under twelve characters, such as one word, is not checked).
  • 58 numbers in the answer, every one computed by fixed rules from the coded passages or the documents' own facts, rather than written by the AI; 0 written by the AI without a count behind them.
  • 0 citations to passages that do not exist; 0 quotations not in the passage they cite.

The check

A separate reader read the answer against the passages it cites and the documents, and checked every sentence and quotation of the answer against the documents, correcting the coding and the answer where they were wrong. The answer above is the corrected one, recounted after the check.

The check's record check.md
Counts
  • Disagreements ruled: none. No second coder coded these documents (no recode/disagreements.md), so there was no ruling for the rows, for the second coder or left unsettled (0 / 0 / 0).
  • Rows changed in step f: 4 (2 removed, 2 recoded). Status rows changed: 0. Definitions changed in workflow.json: 0.
  • Key claims changed in judged/k.json: 3 (position, timemgr, expectation).
  • Rows added for omissions: 0. Claims corrected after the omission search: 6.
  • Sentences of answer.md changed, added or removed: about 45, plus 2 lines added under Limitations.

All 13 interviews and both background documents were read in full. The final recount reports no faults. Its one audit warning (status value "unclear" never used) is correct: every interview states clearly whether the attender delivered.

Rows changed (drafts/parts, then combine, build_codebook and recount)
  • AP4, f.cgwaq, removed (was barrier/own/actual, Line manager). "she kind of I would say almost brushed it off, didn't think too much of it." This was the line manager's first reaction when AP4 signed up for the session. The manager then came round (f.rgsxw), AP4 calls management "Totally supportive" (f.dyq92), and AP4 says the work is self-directed. AP4 never links that first reaction to delivering late, so it is not a barrier to delivery. Effect: label by item and cascaded (barrier, own, actual)[Line manager,No] went from 4 of 6 to 3 of 6.
  • AP2, f.46824, removed (was barrier/own/actual, Trainer confidence). "my skills need to be sort of refreshed". The interviewer had asked whether AP2's attitude to MECC had changed. AP2 says next that the course refreshed those skills and gave "the confidence as well", and that AP2 felt confident to deliver afterwards. It is not a barrier after the session. Effect: label by item and cascaded (barrier, own, actual)[Trainer confidence,No] went from 3 of 6 to 2 of 6, which now matches the report's "two attenders who did not cascade".
  • AP4, f.ab58n, actual changed to prospective. "there were potentially people on the course who ... maybe didn't necessarily want to go and cascade". This is a guess about others with no instance. No count changed, because label by item and kind (others) does not filter on actual.
  • AP10, f.5nz72, actual changed to prospective. "I don't know whether ... it was sort of like nerves on her end". This is a guess about the line manager. No count changed.
  • Lines for f.cgwaq and f.46824 were removed from drafts/rowmap.txt and the codebook was rebuilt. Code: work/check_edits.py.
Key claims changed (judged/k.json)
  • position: the claim said every cascader delivered from a job that included training. AP12 and AP3 do not, and AP1, AP4 and AP10 had backing or a training role without delivering. The claim was reworded. f.rkw6w, f.fnsnn and f.svuu6 were added as rows against it, and the "why" was updated.
  • timemgr: f.cgwaq was removed, and line managers are now given as a barrier "for some".
  • expectation: f.gf48e was added against it. AP3 says AP3's council has "always kind of made it explicit".
Sentences changed in answer.md (document, passage, why)
  • Opening: "mostly those whose organisation wanted it delivered and whose job already included training" was narrowed. Organisational backing is 7 of 7 against 2 of 6, but job role is 5 of 7 against 3 of 6 (AP10 f.svuu6, AP4 f.9ff6z, AP6 f.9qdys), so that difference is unclear.
  • Opening: line managers became a barrier "for some", with the counts after the AP4 correction.
  • Opening: "it holds case by case" was removed. AP1 and AP6 had organisational backing without cascading. The certainty statement now names what is fairly sure (backing and time) and what is not (job role, line managers). The AP6 qualifier in the opening was cut because the "Who counts" section states it.
  • Opening bullet: "never restarted" was changed to "while the training faded". AP9's cascade did restart (f.7rz2u), and AP5 reconvened some trainers (f.8xh9n).
  • Organisational backing was labelled clear and job role unclear, each once, in the section that sets the finding out.
  • AP9 pay: "only on the cascading side" (2 of 7 against 0 of 6) is now labelled unclear. AP6's "I get nothing for it" now carries AP6's own qualifier, that delivery comes from "my own passion" (f.krjpn, AP6 lines 202–208).
  • "AP12 (NHS) is the exception on job role. Training was not part of the job" was corrected. AP12 never says delivery is outside the job, and AP3 is also outside the job-role cell (f.sgmjh, f.6ccbj). The induction-time point now keeps AP12's own words, "a little bit more time at the moment".
  • AP11: the managers being worried about time is now given as what AP11 thinks ("I think they are worried").
  • "more ready routes to an audience" (6 of 7 against 3 of 6) is now labelled unclear.
  • "Mostly this was co-delivery that had been arranged but not yet carried out" was replaced. Only AP1's co-delivery was arranged (f.cr7wy). AP2 had only an offer (f.jc2v8, "she said do you want to do the course together"). AP10's row is about past team practice, and AP6's is observing.
  • Accounts against the backing finding: AP1 was added (f.rkw6w, f.fnsnn; sessions still to come in December). AP4's answer was added: having delivery in the job plan would help "Not for me" (f.9ff6z, AP4 lines 68–72).
  • Time: labelled clear. AP2's trustee duties now keep AP2's hedge, "I wouldn't say it's hugely time consuming" (f.5vj3t). AP10's time and staff-shortage remark is now placed after AP10 left (AP10 lines 196–200). AP10 is named against the finding: AP10 called the sign-off "the only issue" (line 116). "AP12 notes" became "expects", because f.damhb is prospective.
  • Line manager: the AP4 "brushed it off" bullet was removed, and the difference (3 of 6 against 1 of 7) is labelled unclear.
  • "Two further barriers are reported mainly by those who did not cascade" was wrong. Follow-up is 2 of 6 against 2 of 7, support 5 of 6 against 4 of 7, and platforms 4 of 6 against 3 of 7. It now says they were reported on both sides. AP8's dropped follow-up call now says why it was dropped: the caller heard of AP8's circumstances (AP8 line 148).
  • AP8 and expectation: a manager had asked AP8 to be the team's trainer (AP8 line 32), so the bullet now says AP8 took in what that meant only in the room. It no longer suggests AP8 did not know delivery was expected.
  • "stopped AP8" became "made AP8 'just shelve that'". The crisis delayed AP8, who later put off delivery because of work and an appraisal (AP8 line 130).
  • AP5: "staff said" became "people were saying", which is AP5's report of discussions in meetings (AP5 line 58).
  • Other attenders: AP1, AP2 and AP4 were added to the list of interviewees giving such accounts (they have rows with whose "others", and AP4 was already quoted in that section). Confidence as the commonest account now notes that AP9's and AP10's accounts are guesses (f.v34vg "I bet", f.5nz72 "I don't know whether"). AP9's bullet now keeps AP9's words and AP9's guess that the roll-out "probably hasn't happened" (f.efpxb). The quoted fragment no longer reads as a causal claim.
  • AP4's account of others now keeps its hedges, "potentially" and "maybe" (f.ab58n). AP3's statement that the expectation is "made explicit" (f.gf48e) was added against the expectation finding.
  • AP13 job role now keeps "probably" (f.5fd85). The f.gpwb4 bullet now says the speaker is AP13, about trainees in AP13's trust.
  • COVID: "stalled after COVID" became "when COVID struck". AP3's earlier group now carries AP3's words "most people disengaged" (f.qmmr5).
  • The general strategies were put to interviewees by the interviewer: every topic guide ends by asking about refresher training and peer support networks. So "interviewees most often named" became the interviewer "put two strategies to them". AP1's doubt about refreshers was added ("I don't know if refresher Train the Trainer would really work", AP1 line 256). "Where such support already runs, few use it" became "Where the leads already run such support, few come", which is the two cases given. AP12's quote is now cited (f.cguem).
  • AP6's status: "an adapted MECC session" became "MECC within care certificate training". AP6 describes delivering at care-certificate level (AP6 lines 82, 270), not an adapted core session.
  • Limitations: three lines were added (see Narrow judgements). No knowledge/ sources or page numbers are cited in the report, so there was nothing to check against knowledge/.
Omissions found

The search covered every count and every "all / every / only / none / mostly" sentence, through the documents outside the cell. No passage was found that the definitions plainly fit and that both coders had missed, so no row was added. These passages were weighed and not added:

  • label by item and cascaded (facilitator, own, actual)[Organisational priority,No] (2 of 6). AP8: "I know there's a trust expectation because we were told that at the training". AP10: the organisation commissioned bespoke slides. Neither is described as helping delivery (AP8 calls it ticking a box; AP10's held delivery up), so they stay out. Both are under Limitations.
  • label by item and kind (others)[Time and workload,barrier] (5 of 13). AP9: "I'm probably fitting it into a role that they're already busy" (f.fmg89, coded general). It is a fair call whether this is about people AP9 met on the course. It was left as coded, and no stated contrast depends on it.
  • label by item and cascaded (facilitator, own, actual)[Pay and incentives,No] = 0 ("only on the cascading side"). No non-cascader describes funding actually in place. AP4's and AP6's incentive ideas are suggestions. The claim stands.
  • label by item and cascaded (barrier, own, actual)[Knowing delivery was expected,Yes] = 0. AP3's "I didn't know" (AP3 line 197) is about whether AP3 would deliver or coordinate, not a barrier. The claim stands.

The search did contradict some stated contrasts and absences. These claims were corrected (listed above): the follow-up, support and platform barriers "mainly" among those who did not cascade; co-delivery "mostly" arranged; the list of who reported on other attenders; the backing finding's accounts against (AP1, and AP4 on job plan); expectation (AP3 made it explicit); refreshers (AP1 against).

Narrow judgements

recount/tables.md gives no margins, because this workflow has no judge step. Each difference was therefore tested by hand: does the smaller group's share stay under half the larger one's when one document is read the other way, in the less favourable direction?

1. Organisational backing separates the groups (clear; 7 of 7 against 2 of 6, label by item and cascaded (facilitator, own, actual)[Organisational priority,No]). It rests on the ORG facilitator rows and on not counting AP8's trust expectation or AP10's organisation's stalled slide work as backing. AP12's backing (f.kjrbj, "as long as you're going to use it") is a mild reading, but without it the result is 6 of 7 and the finding stands. AP8 and AP10 read the other way together would make it unclear. Could go the other way; a Limitations line was added. 2. Time separates the groups (clear; 6 of 6 against 2 of 7). AP10's place in it rests on remarks about the period after AP10 left (f.qqzpe, f.afpdn), and AP2's on hedged rows. Read the other way, 5 of 6 or even 4 of 6 against 2 of 7 is still clear. The finding stands, so no line was added. AP10 is named in the main text as an account against it. 3. Job role (unclear; 5 of 7 against 3 of 6). It rests on reading AP4 (f.9ff6z, a self-directed role) and AP10 (f.svuu6, usual training roll-outs) as roles that included or allowed delivery. AP4's reading is a fair call either way. Read the other way for both, the difference would be clear. Could go the other way; a Limitations line was added. 4. Line managers (unclear; 3 of 6 against 1 of 7). The difference was 4 of 6, and clear, before f.cgwaq was removed. I removed that row as not a barrier to delivery under the definition, so I added no Limitations line. But a reader who counts a manager's first lukewarm reaction as a barrier would make this difference clear. This is the judgement most open to challenge. 5. Confidence did not separate the groups. This rests on the confidence rows on both sides. With or without AP2's removed row (2 or 3 of 6 against 4 of 7), the finding stands. No line was added. 6. Lack of confidence is the commonest account of other attenders (7 of 13 against 6 of 13). It leads by one, and it rests on AP9's guess (f.v34vg) being counted as about specific attenders. Read as a general view, the two would be level. Could go the other way; a Limitations line was added. 7. Not knowing delivery was expected (3 of 6 against 0 of 7). The report does not call this difference clear. AP4's and AP8's readings are fair calls, but the report makes no firm claim on it, so no line was added.

The record

This is run 2026-10-22-sb4m. Its ID stays the same through every revision, and the zip's fingerprint, below, names this version of it. This report was created directly from the run's zip, what-stopped-attenders-of-the-mecc-train-the-2026-11-10-99e23880.zip, with Rubicon 0.1.8+70a5d58db852. The zip's fingerprint is 99e23880eb843919de85e77c62601cf7197cb81d26f14a681562d6fca25bb6fa. It is the SHA-256 of the zip's SHA256SUMS file, which lists the SHA-256 of every other file in the zip, so changing any file breaks the match. To check that the zip is the one this report was created from, unzip it, run sha256sum -c SHA256SUMS, then sha256sum SHA256SUMS, and compare the result with the fingerprint above. Rubicon's own fixed rules check the rest: python verify.py <report> <zip> recounts every number in the zip from the coded passages or the documents' own facts, creates the report again from the zip and says whether it matches this one exactly.

Every interview at a glance

Each row is one interview, each column a reason as the coding defines it. Click a mark to read the passages.

No
Yes
🔥 Carbon cost of this report: Between 0.02 and 2.8 km driven in an average UK family car

Making this report used between 27.1 and 3727 watt-hours of electricity, which is the carbon of driving an average UK family car for that distance. A ballpark only: Anthropic publishes no energy figures, and the run, made in the evaluator's own Claude, records no token counts, so the estimate is made from the run's size. The 15 documents were read in full once by each of the 2 coding steps, by the second coder and by the check, and the writer read the tables; everything the run wrote counts as output. That comes to about 907,562 tokens read and 96,364 written, at 4 characters a token.

  • High: 0.39 Wh per thousand tokens read and 1.95 per thousand written, with what was read counted 10 times over for the agent's own overhead. Simon P. Couch, 'Electricity use of AI coding agents', 20 January 2026, https://simonpcouch.com/blog/2026-01-20-cc-impact/: about 390 Wh per million input tokens and 1,950 per million output tokens for Claude Opus, back-solved from Epoch AI's estimate for a 100,000-token prompt with output at five times the input rate, as Anthropic's prices are. The author calls them napkin maths. Our assumption, not a measurement: an agent re-sends its instructions, earlier turns and tool output with every request, so it reads far more than the documents themselves. The low case counts only what was read and written; the high case counts what was read ten times over.
  • Low: the same rates divided by 20, what was read counted once. Oviedo et al., 'Energy use of AI inference, efficiency pathways, and test-time scaling', arXiv:2509.20241: a median 0.31 Wh per query for frontier models, and widely cited estimates overstated by 4 to 20 times. The low case takes the high case's rates divided by the top of that range.
  • 0.124 kg CO2e per kWh. DESNZ greenhouse gas reporting conversion factors, UK grid electricity, 2024.
  • 0.16601 kg CO2e per km. DESNZ greenhouse gas reporting conversion factors, average car of unknown fuel, 2024.

Made with Rubicon by Causal Map, free for Claude: rubicon.causalmap.app